James McCarthy

Daveysgingerlovechild · July 20, 2018

Was great in his first season here. But the hamstring curse ruined him from season 2.

Connor · July 31, 2018

SOON.

Azza · July 31, 2018

Has he been on a diet?!

mightymoyes · July 31, 2018

Connor said:
SOON.

Injured again within first month back guaranteed

jackyboy · July 31, 2018

Yersssss!

Barnfred 55 · July 31, 2018

LydiateLee · July 31, 2018

Love James McCarthy, we always look a better side when he plays.
Best CM we have by a long stretch.

jrj · July 31, 2018

Rather have him than Schneid

PhilM · July 31, 2018

LydiateLee said:
Love James McCarthy, we always look a better side when he plays.
Best CM we have by a long stretch.

Nostalgia getting the better of you? McCarthy, amongst others, had a stellar first season but for me he's been pretty average since then, bar a few stellar games.

You could say that about a lot of players though and he's not going to fix our lack of creativity in the middle by offering forward passes and/or dynamic movement.

Clearly he'll offer more in terms of tenacity and determination that Morgan, but in terms of footballing ability he's below him; merely an alternative for him or Gana.

Connor · July 31, 2018

First name on the team sheet after Pickford once he's fit

Rudolf Hucker · July 31, 2018

Get rid immediately.

Pseudonym · July 31, 2018

If he stayed fit, we'd be a lot better for it.

hktoffee · July 31, 2018

Get rid now. Can pass a medical.

PhilM · July 31, 2018

Pseudonym said:
If he stayed fit, we'd be a lot better for it.

Obviously the horrific challenge was not his fault, however over his time here the problem has been that he seems unable to stay fit. This is his sixth season here!