James McCarthy

[ToffeeTim]

That's an excellent offer and good for all concerned.

He was a decent player but injuries have been real hard on him and we need players who are fit and available.

 

[Exeter_Gently]

£8m for 3 years horizontal?

Christ wonder what we’d get selling @MarcelsGoat then; that space whale hasn’t stood up in 11 years.

Wow

 

[davek]

If he goes for £8M, that'll be a net profit on Martinez signings of £36M - thus far.


And if anyone's having a go at McCarthy's quality they have very short memories and / or are clueless about football, because he was easily our best DM since Carsley.

 

[Joey66]

Must say he kicked a few players coming on today

 

[ToffeeTim]

If he goes for £8M, that'll be a net profit on Martinez signings of £36M - thus far.


And if anyone's having a go at McCarthy's quality they have very short memories and / or are clueless about football, because he was easily our best DM since Carsley.

He was excellent for a couple of seasons. Then injuries took their toll on him and he was treated terribly by Martin O Neill. It's time to sell though because we need players who are dynamic and available for the majority of the season.

 

[Blues Harp]

If he goes for £8M, that'll be a net profit on Martinez signings of £36M - thus far.


And if anyone's having a go at McCarthy's quality they have very short memories and / or are clueless about football, because he was easily our best DM since Carsley.

Deluded you...... lol lol lol lol ......another Wigan dud gone hopefully.....

 

[Groucho]

If he goes for £8M, that'll be a net profit on Martinez signings of £36M - thus far.


And if anyone's having a go at McCarthy's quality they have very short memories and / or are clueless about football, because he was easily our best DM since Carsley.

Deluded you...... lol lol lol lol ......another Wigan dud gone hopefully.....

Dave's right that he was a good player, but only when fit.

 

[rochdaleblue]

If he goes for £8M, that'll be a net profit on Martinez signings of £36M - thus far.


And if anyone's having a go at McCarthy's quality they have very short memories and / or are clueless about football, because he was easily our best DM since Carsley.

I don’t think anybody is having a go at his quality, but he’s barely kicked a ball for us in 3 years. That’s through no fault of his own, but he’s never been able to recapture the form of his first season, which is hardly surprising due to the cruel succession of injuries he’s had. It would be a good move for all parties concerned.

 

[MikeH72]

Not celebrating until he’s holding up the shirt.

 

[Kantareller]

Come on Palace

Don't you dare chicken out

 

[Saint Domingo]

If he goes for £8M, that'll be a net profit on Martinez signings of £36M - thus far.


And if anyone's having a go at McCarthy's quality they have very short memories and / or are clueless about football, because he was easily our best DM since Carsley.

Considering we sold Lukaku for approx 50 mill profit that doesn’t say much for his other signings.

 

[PhilRegan]

Goodbye McCarthy goodbye Gueye. Hello again Delph.

 

[rochdaleblue]

Considering we sold Lukaku for approx 50 mill that doesn’t say much for his other signings.

And we’re still lumbered with niasse.

 

[nsno-chris]

If he goes for £8M, that'll be a net profit on Martinez signings of £36M - thus far.


And if anyone's having a go at McCarthy's quality they have very short memories and / or are clueless about football, because he was easily our best DM since Carsley.

Bought for 13, sold for 8. No profit on McCarthy pal

 

[Lob]

Accept the offer Marcel and dont let him play even another second of football, in fact dont even let him train because it is an absolute certainty that he will break something and be injured till his contract runs out. Would be made up getting 8 mill for him.