2025/26 James Garner

Garner doesn't lose out to anyone,
I said it was a silly comparison.

Garner has already controlled
Anderson
Wharton
Fernandez
Scott
And held his head high with Rice.

Wharton was the real motm when we played them (as per Grealish) and i'd say Anderson gave him a very good test.

Those two looked better than Rice to me...in the one game each :)
 
Wharton was the real motm when we played them (as per Grealish) and i'd say Anderson gave him a very good test.

Those two looked better than Rice to me...in the one game each :)

We beat Forrest
We beat Palace
We beat Utd
We beat Bournemouth
We gave Aresnal a win

So who comes out on top, Garner...
 
🤣 People think Garner matched Rice, incredible. There is a reason Rice plays for Arsenal and Garner doesn't and never will get to that level, even worse shouts Garner and England get to ....
 
Wharton was the real motm when we played them (as per Grealish) and i'd say Anderson gave him a very good test.

Those two looked better than Rice to me...in the one game each :)

Anderson is better than Garner, but he didn't show anything in that 3-0 game the other week imo.

I like Garner. He's very good, probably not great, and could get to the World Cup with a couple of injuries to others.

Rice, Wharton, Anderson, Henderson, James and obviously Bellingham all ahead of him though. And I think that's basically fair enough when factoring in quality, form and leadership.
 
I'm aware. I'm just pointing out it's ridiculous for people to say they matched them, they didn't, at all.

The Midfielders that keep getting mentioned are of serious quality, Garner always gets played down, so it was a perfect summary of how he matched up in games this season.

Rice cost more than our whole best midfield on his own.
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top