Everton Total Football

[Brennan]

Have you just actually said who is Oscar & a "nope" next to Yaya Toure? As in African player of the year 2011 and PFA team of the year? And ex Barca? ( 6 trophies in 2010 season..)

Don't know why you're bothering. Obvious belter is obvious.

The argument of us having the 'most versatile' squad is redundant anyway, as the reason teams like United don't need to move players all over the pitch is because they have depth.

'Versatility' more like 'No depth'. I'm sure Valencia could probably do a job in the hole as well as at right back like.

 

[Phyllis Stein]

Have you just actually said who is Oscar & a "nope" next to Yaya Toure? As in African player of the year 2011 and PFA team of the year? And ex Barca? ( 6 trophies in 2010 season..)

Didn't you say you'd hang fire on Naismith and Mirallas? Because Oscar has played how many for Chelsea so far?
And Yaya Toure might be the greatest player to ever grace the game and have the accolades to prove it, but I havn't seen him play anything other than basic midfielder at City. Also it needs to be noted that the two sides you have plucked players from and only from skew the arguement as they have the funds to keep all sorts on the bench, Milner and Barry being very similar are a case in point.
Moyes has had to buy players that can cover for others, City specifically have a few versatile players to cover other positions but have out and out specialists like De Jong, Silva, Nasri (Silva and Nasri effectively being the same player like Milner and Barry).

 

[Phyllis Stein]

Don't know why you're bothering. Obvious belter is obvious.

And you bothered because.... ?

 

[Parkender]

Why are we all being so mean to each other?

 

[Brennan]

Fellaini has played for us, under Moyes, DM, M, AM.
Pienaar has played for us, under Moyes, LM, M, AM, RM.
Osman has played for us, under Moyes, every midfield position imaginable.
Naismith has played for Rangers and Scotland RM, AM, Striker.
Mirallas has played for Belgium and Olympiacos RM, AM, Striker.

Didn't you say you'd hang fire on Naismith and Mirallas? Because Oscar has played how many for Chelsea so far?
And Yaya Toure might be the greatest player to ever grace the game and have the accolades to prove it, but I havn't seen him play anything other than basic midfielder at City. Also it needs to be noted that the two sides you have plucked players from and only from skew the arguement as they have the funds to keep all sorts on the bench, Milner and Barry being very similar are a case in point.
Moyes has had to buy players that can cover for others, City specifically have a few versatile players to cover other positions but have out and out specialists like De Jong, Silva, Nasri (Silva and Nasri effectively being the same player like Milner and Barry).

Hasn't played anything other than a basic midfielder. Oh my giddy aunt.

 

[Brennan]

And you bothered because.... ?

Simply stating a fact. This thread is f***ing cringe worthy and if a Kopite had said it about the RS had they won at West Brom we'd be laughing our tits off at them.

 

[Phyllis Stein]

Uh....

Naismith got on last night mate. Stick a 'D' before that then yeah.

 

[Del]

Simply stating a fact. This thread is f***ing cringe worthy and if a Kopite had said it about the RS had they won at West Brom we'd be laughing our tits off at them.

This on toast lad

We have won 1 game ffs

 

[Phyllis Stein]

Simply stating a fact. This thread is f***ing cringe worthy and if a Kopite had said it about the RS had they won at West Brom we'd be laughing our tits off at them.

A fact according to you. You have your opinion on facts, I have my opinions
I dont give two flying ones what the RS think say or do.
And I stand by my 30 league goals from midfield this season.

 

[Brennan]

Naismith got on last night mate. Stick a 'D' before that then yeah.

So because Naismith played once for us, for about ten minutes, you can suddenly say he's a versatile player ? You're a total hypocrite, his performance gives you zero to go on and thus Oscar can be judged just as fairly as Naismith can.

 

[Brennan]

A fact according to you. You have your opinion on facts, I have my opinions
I dont give two flying ones what the RS think say or do.
And I stand by my 30 league goals from midfield this season.

So you've never made one comment on this forum about the RS doing or saying something stupid ? Do i have to go in the vaults ?

 

[Deleted member 28206]

Didn't you say you'd hang fire on Naismith and Mirallas? Because Oscar has played how many for Chelsea so far?
And Yaya Toure might be the greatest player to ever grace the game and have the accolades to prove it, but I havn't seen him play anything other than basic midfielder at City. Also it needs to be noted that the two sides you have plucked players from and only from skew the arguement as they have the funds to keep all sorts on the bench, Milner and Barry being very similar are a case in point.
Moyes has had to buy players that can cover for others, City specifically have a few versatile players to cover other positions but have out and out specialists like De Jong, Silva, Nasri (Silva and Nasri effectively being the same player like Milner and Barry).

You asked me to name other midfielders,you didn't restrict my choices.

This can be a debate without the argumentive nature and KOPITE shouts too please

 

[Phyllis Stein]

So because Naismith played once for us, for about ten minutes, you can suddenly say he's a versatile player ? You're a total hypocrite, his performance gives you zero to go on and thus Oscar can be judged just as fairly as Naismith can.

Oh really, because Oscar has played the same 10 minutes for Chelsea?
Better than that, has Oscar played for an International side from these Isles?
Better than that, has Oscar played for any other side in any other League from these Isles?
Better than that, has Oscar played 30+ games at domestic level with anyone else in his new team?

Its ok mate, carry on.

 

[Goat]

So you've never made one comment on this forum about the RS doing or saying something stupid ? Do i have to go in the vaults ?

Thats gonna have to be some vault search.

His accounts stretch as far back as 07.

 

[Phyllis Stein]

This can be a debate without the argumentive nature and KOPITE shouts too please

Two to Tango, and what KOPITE shouts?