If he's struggling to figure out who is good and isn't right now just imagine how it will go when he's got 10+ new players in August. I'd say his performance the last few months has shown every reason why he should not be brought back after the next two weeks run their course.
I didn't rate his starting 11 today but I'd rather get proven wrong by the manager when it results in a win.
How can you argue his performance the past few months has been a negative?
He's made us extremely hard to beat and with a bit more luck and better refereeing we'd have earned even more points.
He's not faultless and he makes some frustrating decisions but overall
Moyes has shown he is the best man for the job in the short to medium term at least. He will have us back in the top 10 within a season or 2 and maybe even back in Europe. Wouldn't be surprised if we won a Conference League under him. Then there will be Evertonians saying we are celebrating failure cause it's not winning the League as if the last 40 years haven't happened.