Saying that he doesn't want to talk about lack of funds...and then talking constantly about lack of funds
Oh, yeah. I'm glad I'm not the only one who has noticed that.
Sticking to his guns in the transfer market...until the very last week, then selling star players and barely - if at all - getting replacements in
It's not a bug, it's a feature. The Moyes blueprint for selling players (post-Rooney) is pretty clear - never announce that you want rid of a player; never agree to the first offer you receive; always drag it out for as long as possible; always claim that you don't have or want to sell the player. Generally, it has worked - the bidders have been hooked and have tended to overpay. I would argue that between Lescott, McFadden, AJ and even Anderson de Silva, Naysmith, S. Davies and Bent, this strategy has generated at least 20 million more than if they had been sold at a "true" value. The downside is not only the short span for getting replacements in, but also the fact that a lot of the players will simply not be sold, thus leading to situations when they will leave on frees or retire. West Ham called his bluff on the Yak, so others may be getting wise to this strategy as well.
I will not consider Moyes's stubbornness as a gaffe, it defines him as a manager. Yes, it makes him far too rigid with his formation and selection; yes, it means that he's unable to make a game-changing substitution. It also means that he's never going to accept that our competitors have more money and better squads, so it's better if we set our targets low. He's probably the only person in the world who saw our squad in 04/05 as capable of finishing in the CL places.
However, his greatest gaffe
may be that he has bought into the "best squad in 20 years" hype and he
may have squandered years of fiscal prudence for a mad push for the CL this season. Since Lescott's departure, our weekly wages have exploded by (at least) 200 000£/25% without any corresponding increase in results. The TV deals have helped, but there are no indications that our turnover is substantially better. It
may turn out that our commercial department has got much better, we
may yet qualify for the CL, and when the 09/10 fiscal report comes out this may turn out to be fear-mongering. But right now it appears that we will either have to dismantle the squad after this (or possibly the next) season OR we'll collapse if the next TV deal isn't as good as the present.
My support for the Moyes/Kenwright leadership has always been based on the premise that if/when the football bubble bursts, Everton will be well poised to take the place of at least 3 of the present Sky 4 clubs. Due to Moyes's profligacy this
may no longer be the case.