Just scan read thru all 55 pages, few people on here really dislike him and don't rate him at all. Thought they might have come around eventually but not so far.
Did these same people rate Carsley or the pre-gashness Neville?
He's playing the David Batty role well and has much more to his game than the basic Batty model in that the ball can actually go forward from his passes, he's got a shot with either feet (and the balls to use it), and he's got a lot more pace than you realise and chases back like a dog.
(edited for grammar and to break the wall of text)