Barkley was out for a while around last January too wasn't he?
I get your point on Gibson but before last season he did sporadically miss games, but his lack of appearance is down to not making the first team at United rather than injuries. Who knows? Maybe his luck is gonna turn for the better, rather than be another Norman Whiteside.
If he can get a prolonged run of games then he's as good as any centre mid we have at the club.
I think he got injured and missed one or two games, but by then he'd lost his place for a fair bit i think. Martinez preferred using him off the bench if i recall correctly?
I do hope his luck does turn around but i do think his career will always be one of injuries. I think he was very important to us at a time where we had no midfielders of his ilk and with the passing ability he became very important to the way we play.
I do think because he hasn't actually played in the team were now we have a lot more of those players he does actually become less special and less important to us, but because we haven't had the chance to witness that people always look back more fondly on him because of just how important he was. But he isn't anymore.
If i'm being brutally honest i think if Martinez was to let anyone go from our CM's he'd be the first out the door, as sad as it is i can eventually see him going to a side like Villa (probably someone better than villa) and being very important to them but also being very injury prone once again.
I think he will always be a 40-80 games a club player instead of going on to make hundreds of appearances.
That's just my opinion but i hope i'm wrong! i'm very thankful for what he did but i honestly don't think he's that vital to our squad anymore, we've sort of moved on and evolved. His passing range though is something that will be really useful this season. Can't wait to see him back at goodison if i'm honest.