Now you mention halo, that brings me to another idea of why gears didn't sit right with me. I bought an original Xbox because of halo and became a halo junkie. Loved the linking up of the xboxes, overnight halo parties drinking and having a laugh. Friends bringing over tv's and whatever lol.... good times.
When halo 3 came out I didn't play or play another title for at least 4 years. The halo campaigns were decent but it was the online aspect that I was hooked on. Each to their own and all that but halo 3 hit the spot for me. I loved the 8v8 team battles and how they'd play out, the carnage and just incredible adrenaline rushed fun.
Back in 09/10 I used to go into 8v8 matchmaking daily with the same lads, lads I'd met through playing the game. Regularly being matched against other actual teams of 8, similar to ourselves. There is something very very addictive about that, when 16 decent players are going at it, the smack talking before and after, the different strategies certain teams had and trying to control it.
I'm going off on one now like and sound a right nerd but nothing has come close since for that level of enjoyment online. So maybe halo and my addiction played some part in me not liking gears. You get used to a certain shooter game, the mechanics, buttons etc.
COD 4 was my online gaming highlight
Would literally play that till 5 in the morning online while I was at Uni
I was pretty much a recluse for a month or so
Nothing has ever come close to that. In fact, I hardly play online at all these days