Not the most outlandish senario ever. This is why I was not totally pleased with the who.e 'Vibe' of his appointment...I mean its Moyes ffs.
But like I think you (or somebody) said - we're...some of us...are further ahead on the 'How will Moyes go' curve than TFG.
In the short term both we and TFG got lucky with Sean-I can't take them any further-Dyche's replacement.
The longer he stays, we will probably go to consolidate where we are now - 14th to 8th in our little yo-yo section of the League and compared to this time last year that's pretty good. so fairplay to all.
Moyes can - on past form take us into the top half of our mini yo-yo League - 9th to 5th on a good day
But to my mind, with a medium to long term (3 yrs+) Moyes there always seems to be a law of diminishing returns.
Because deep down
Moyes will be Moyes.
Yes, this is the issue for me. Are we doing better than last year? Of course. Should we be? Of course. Did
Moyes do a good job last season? An excellent one. Is he doing a good job this season? He's doing pretty well. I can understand why fans who have suffered what we have would think, as they look at Wolves:
"Tonight thank God it's them instead of you."
But we've all got to park our inner Bono. We are no longer run by shady ex-Soviets. A different manager under these owners is not a surefire return to the days of Frank Lampard.
Moyes was here to stabilise. That job will be done by May 2026. He will have been here 18 months and we will not have been in a relegation battle since February 2025. The new owners will have had plenty of time to reorganise the club from within and we will have moved stadia. In other words, stability has been achieved.
At that point, we either show ambition or decide the status quo will do. Both are legitimate choices and perspectives - but come with conclusions we need to accept. Let's at least be honest. If you were an owner who really only wanted to safely nurse your investment, why wouldn't you extend Moyes? A safe pair of hands. However, if you, as an owner, wanted to turn back the tide in the city, challenge the establishment, and return Everton to trophy-contending relevance, Moyes would not be the horse for that course - unless you felt you needed another 12 months of "stability" before making the switch.
My position is that if that switch is not made next summer, that's more likely to be because they want to nurse their investment rather than buying themselves more time for an ambitious assault. I don't see what another 12 months buys you...except an older Pickford and
Grealish for a new man to begin to consider replacing. That doesn't scream a good base on which to build.
We live in interesting times. The manager's position will tell a tale in the summer - but so then will the summer window. We'll know exactly where we stand and what we can actually achieve under these new owners then. Right now, they seem less transformative and more Rick Parfitt.