Best 5, Worst 5

kikoefc · July 26, 2008

Just a thread to get away from all the frustration of this transfer window. Who do you think Moyes' top 5 signings and worst 5 have been during his reign at Everton. (Loans do not count) Mine are as follows:

Best
1. Tim Cahill
2. Mikel Arteta
3. Joleon Lescott
4. Nigel Martyn
5. Joseph Yobo

Worst
1. Per Kroldrup
2. Simon Davies
3. James Beattie
4. Richard Wright
5. Li Tie

keverton · July 26, 2008

agree with the 5 best one's but where is van der meyde in the worst, should replace li tie

GrandOldTeam · July 26, 2008

Li Tie wasn't really a Moyes signing, he came as part as the Keijan deal.

Rouse! · July 26, 2008

Agree with the Van Der Meyde shout.

teppic · July 26, 2008

li tie was a first team player in 2002/03 and played well that year we finished 7th.

not bad as we got him for free. surely li wei feng was worse that li tie as he only made the team once?

i think VDM should be in there with kroldrup as they have not played a part in the team. although at least we got money for most of the players except VDM of course.

can't argue with the fab 5 buys but worst 5:

1) VDM
2) kroldrup
3) wright
4) davies
5) beattie

Rouse! · July 26, 2008

Didnt Moyes sign a brazilian that didnt get a game, same time we bought Li Tie, around 02/03?? Rodrigo If i remember right?

teppic · July 26, 2008

thats right. i think it was a year loan and he goosed his knee in pre season.

zero · July 26, 2008

I thought Wright was a decent stopper for a season... was gutted when he started to go [Poor language removed]. :unsure:

Scottoffee · July 26, 2008

Anderson da Silva was a shocker!...

And Pienaar for only 2m or whatever is absolutely brilliant...

roymc1980 · July 26, 2008

I thought lie tie was ok he was good on the ball and wasnt a bad player just a bit lightweight.
TOP 5

Cahill
Arteta
Lescott
Yobo
Stubbs ( 2nd time round )

WORST 5

Kroldrup
Beattie
Da silva
Wright
van de meyde