Back four when/if all are fit?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BigBurger

Player Valuation: £500k
Who would you have as the starting back four when all are fit. With the unearthing of Coleman and Rodwell this season, Senderos just being signed as well as Jags coming back hopefully quite soon there is a likelihood that we will be quite well stocked for defenders. Who would you have as your starting four?
 

What about?

Heitinga---Jags---Rodwell---Baines

no, i'd play Baines and Rodwell in midfield. Baines struggles to get back after his forward runs and isn't as solid in defense as others, therefore til Bily gets his arse into gear i'd play him on the left wing. And play Rodwell in a Carsley role! And i think Jonny would "do a Jags" (before we played him at CB) at right back!
 

Who ever can keep a clean sheet - we've been dreadfull at the back this year with very little consistencey or balance, you can say what you like about strikers or midfeilders but our problem is at the back. How many draws could have been won - quite a few.
 

We need to keep Neville in the side for his leadership qualities. He's lost the midfield anchor position to Fellaini, so it'll have to be right back, even though I'd like to see Coleman given a run there. I think that Heitinga could be another Jagielka once he settles in properly. His distribution is better than Jags and he had a goalscoring record in Holland to match Lescott. Hopefully we'll start to see that part of his game emerge before too long. Baines is the only option at left back. He's not getting forward as well as he did last season and he needs to work on closing wingers down quicker to prevent crosses coming in.

Neville-Jagielka-Heitinga-Baines

Distin hasn't impressed me at all and I can see him leaving in the summer. He'd quite possibly be fifth choice centre back behind Jagielka, Heitinga, Yobo and Senderos and I can't see him settling for that at this stage of his career. Hopefully having to fight for his place will sharpen Yobo up mentally. It remains to be seen what Senderos can offer us. As he's out of contract in the summer, we're effectively getting him on a free now. I can't really see Moyes carrying four senior centre backs in the squad given that we need to be mindful of our wage bill. We may sign him up and move him quickly on for a profit. Seeing as Arsenal have struggled to find a buyer for him over the last 18 months, we may well simply release him instead.

Duffy looks like a good player. He read the game well and was calm and composed during his Europa League outing. If Rindaroy comes in as cover for Baines then we haven't got a bad squad of defenders at our disposal.

Howard certainly needs some competition for his place and hopefully Mucha will provide it. Compared to the form that he showed last season, Tim has had a very disappointing year. Admittedly he hasn't been helped by his defence but, having set a club clean sheet record last term, he has failed to live up to those standards during this campaign. I think I heard in the commentary yesterday that we've managed only 3 shut outs in 33 games. I rarely remember Howard being featured in tv highlights for making saves this season and I can't think of that many Man of the Match awards that he's won.
 
Moyes will pick:

Neville Jags Heitinger Baines

TBM would pick:

Coleman Jags Heitinger Baines

Neville seems better in midfield but with everyone fully fit we will have a problem keeping everyone happy.

I don't care how young Duffy is he needs a go every now and then.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top