Aries
Player Valuation: £15m
Was going to say the same. Maupay is a stick the Thelwell haters like to beat him with but he didn’t want him!
Blue peter
Player Valuation: £35m
I don’t think he’s been bad at all as all DoFs have hits and misses, but it it is difficult to assess exactly how he has done, because he’s had to operate in a far more unfavourable financial and unstable environment than his predecessors, with the same dysfunctional board. Must have been horrendous.
Think the doffer did some terrific business in his final season, I've no doubt other aspects of the organisation have been improved aswell under extremely difficult circumstances. O'brien, Ndiaye and hopefully Alcaraz will be big players for us imo.
A proper football man if ever there was one.
A proper football man if ever there was one.
Zatara
Player Valuation: £100m
A huge loss. How stupid are these yanks to let him go ahead of a pivotal summer window?
I'd be so confident he'd sort our right hand side out with quality at the very least.
tsubaki
Player Valuation: £90m
It is the one mis-step the owners made, letting him go.
salmon fingers
Player Valuation: £750k
I agree! They reckon about 50% of all signings in the prem are a success I would rate Thelwells signings a lot higher than 50% even down to Tim Iroegbunam, we got the best of that deal.
Really would have liked to have seen what he could do without hands tied behind his back.
Thank you Kevin
You have to say, fair play.
I wasn't a fan, maybe lack of striker/Maupay created a blind spot.
It just seems odd to let him go now when this window could define the next few years.
With the scale of ins/outs, Moyes is going to need help and the last two windows were Thelwell's best.
O'Brien, Nidaye, Alcaraz for less than £50m is outstanding business.
It just seems odd to let him go now when this window could define the next few years.
With the scale of ins/outs, Moyes is going to need help and the last two windows were Thelwell's best.
O'Brien, Nidaye, Alcaraz for less than £50m is outstanding business.
brieverton
Player Valuation: £50m
He did bear a lot of criticism (including mine) but felt he did a good job all told.
I agree in theory with Kinnears restructuring so in the end and with the new ownership he wasn't going to stay in any event.
He will do well at Rangers and they should be challenging soon enough.
I agree in theory with Kinnears restructuring so in the end and with the new ownership he wasn't going to stay in any event.
He will do well at Rangers and they should be challenging soon enough.
I’m sure that’s linked to the fact that Kenwright & Moshiri were playing no role in recruitment last season and he could get on and do his job.
He's also spent a bit of time putting systems in place to improve scouting etc, I know that stuff isn't as quantifiable as just reviewing signings, but in the long run its pretty important
Agreed let’s hope it’s not just ditched but built on.
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
