Who is the worst Everton player you have seen in the Premier League era?

[FinnTrikker]

Pound for pound nobody even close to Iwobbli......shame on those calling for Backodaecho,his goals at Blackburn when one down probably kept us up in 97,great memories of that..

correction...was 99,not such great memory afterall...

 

[billyblue80]

Nyarko not on the list?

 

[Sinski]

Cuco Ronwobi

 

[Yarrgh]

Nyarko not on the list?

Just thinking that. He was a waste of space too.

 

[billyblue80]

We could be about to put one of our worst ever forward lines out this weekend

 

[Papa Shango]

1 goal in 20 appearances. He did run into people a lot, I'll give you that.

But 1 goal in 1 appearance Traore was going to be your choice!

I didn't mind the little I saw of him, scored straight away, almost got another with a back heel then fell apart never to be seen again (I think he got 10 minutes in another game).

It would be fair to see he has not had a glittering career since then though.

 

[Simon Buttle]

He was still appalling. I mean it's baffling to me the regard that Ferguson is held in but this guy was just plain awful. He should have been playing non-league.

Still playing in the Italian 4th tier

 

[evertonmatt88]

Earl Barrett

 

[BlueAmigo]

Alex Nyarko

 

[BNJ1878]

Obvious recency bias, but Rondon.... By an absolute mile.

He looks COMPLETELY finished at this level.

 

[kiss the crest]

How come there are only 2 players from the current crop on there?

 

[jonesey10]

No more needs to be saidView attachment 146447

My 12 year old son could pick that pass out and he's left footed!! shocking that a pro footballer makes a 'balls up' from that position.

 

[barneygumble]

Still maintain it's Davies.

140 appearances, and if he hadn't scored a wonder goal against City on his debut, would he even be near the team? 140 league appearances, and we don't know his position. Christ. At least we know where Iwobi is meant to "play".

 

[Jamalio Danubio DiCanio]

There's been a few contenders. There's worst players - as in terms of ability - and there's worst signing - which I think needs to take into context fee as well as performance.

In terms of signings I think Sandro, Bolasie and Nyarko would be hard to beat. With those players their Everton career is known and the monetary cost to what they gave isn't going to change.

Someone like Iwobi could end up on that list. Though he has ability and has time to turn things around.

Worst player in terms of ability is probably Brett Angell. Tony Thomas and a few of the GKs are up there as well.

Someone like Rondon isn't showing anything at the moment but he has some sort of pedigree. Tony Thomas and Brett Angell were never at the level to play regular PL football

 

[MACCA75]

There's been a few contenders. There's worst players - as in terms of ability - and there's worst signing - which I think needs to take into context fee as well as performance.

In terms of signings I think Sandro, Bolasie and Nyarko would be hard to beat. With those players their Everton career is known and the monetary cost to what they gave isn't going to change.

Someone like Iwobi could end up on that list. Though he has ability and has time to turn things around.

Worst player in terms of ability is probably Brett Angell. Tony Thomas and a few of the GKs are up there as well.

Someone like Rondon isn't showing anything at the moment but he has some sort of pedigree. Tony Thomas and Brett Angell were never at the level to play regular PL football

Good shout for the keepers. Paul Gerrard getting off Scot-free here.