2018/19 Michael Keane

Status
Not open for further replies.

evertonarntwe said:
he's been 10 fold better than last season, but wouldn't say very good.

not going to sit here and review each game obviously but one mistake? rubbish lad
Click to expand...
All opinions lad, but all I'm saying is a lot of people suddenly developed a negative opinion or started piping up purely because he made one mistake. Not on about you, but in the general consensus of the forum is that he's been good this year and all of a sudden he's rubbish again because we as a team are going through some bad form.
 
He's been an improvement on last season, but he's still whack. Zouma also isn't the answer to our prayers, but better than Keane imo, so get him in alongside Mina until end of season and ship out Keane in the summer; I am sure Burnley would take him back for 10m or so.
 

Big Fat Sam said:
He's been an improvement on last season, but he's still whack. Zouma also isn't the answer to our prayers, but better than Keane imo, so get him in alongside Mina until end of season and ship out Keane in the summer; I am sure Burnley would take him back for 10m or so.
Click to expand...

That's the problem. Mina was absolutely awful at Brighton. There's no easy answer.

evertonarntwe said:
he's been 10 fold better than last season, but wouldn't say very good.

not going to sit here and review each game obviously but one mistake? rubbish lad
Click to expand...

He made quite a bad mistake in the derby that he was very lucky not to get punished for. Again miscontrolled the ball and let it right through him gifting one of their attackers a one on one with Pickford which they missed.
 
Manx Blue said:
Very much so, in fact he’s been excellent along with Digne probably our best player.
Click to expand...

don't ever compare digne with keane again or you shall be shot

in all seriousness though, keane has been ok, but he's to slow to ever be very good. he'll only ever be a good defender in a team like burnley who have a low defensive line

he costs us a chance ( at least ) every game because me mars faster than him, and shes a buffalo
 
I thought he was playing very well against Leicester. Vardy did not have a look at goal.
Then, he made that awful mistake that cost us the game, but I don't think we should ignore that he was very solid apart from that moment.
 

blueblue said:
I thought he was playing very well against Leicester. Vardy did not have a look at goal.
Then, he made that awful mistake that cost us the game, but I don't think we should ignore that he was very solid apart from that moment.
Click to expand...

You can't ignore it though. That's the problem. If a defender has a great game each week apart from one mistake that costs a goal then he never has a good game.

Life is harsh on defenders but you simply can't make mistakes.
 
Our best combination at the moment is Keane and zouma if we play 2. Can't complain about Keane's mistakes and ignore some of the howlers Mina has made in his limited game time.
 
Papa Shango said:
You can't ignore it though. That's the problem. If a defender has a great game each week apart from one mistake that costs a goal then he never has a good game.

Life is harsh on defenders but you simply can't make mistakes.
Click to expand...

Unless our strikers also have a good game and score more than he is liable for. Wish we had some good strikers....
 
Jimmy Grimble said:
Our best combination at the moment is Keane and zouma if we play 2. Can't complain about Keane's mistakes and ignore some of the howlers Mina has made in his limited game time.
Click to expand...

Its Mina and Zouma for me. Mina at least has an excuse of not being here long. He is also more of a threat at the other end.

Annoyingly I think the best of the three is the one we don't actually own.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top