2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

Grade Marco Silva's 2018/19 Season

  • A

  • B

  • C

  • D

  • E

  • F


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Was with Utd mate if I remember correctly?

Sure he won Europa, FA and League cups.

He's doing poorly with a poor Utd side full of ego's. He isn't the Jose of old I agree but he's still a million miles better than Silva or any Everton manager of recent memory.

Wrong, only won Europa and Carabao, they got knocked out as holders by Chelsea in the Quarters
 
Ye just like Martinez, he just won the fa cup, this is the young up andcoming manager to take us forward.

Just like Koeman, he did well at Southampton despite losing most of his best players, this is the guy to take us forward

Silva, he plays attractive football, this is the guy to take us forward

How about signing an experienced manager that has a track record of managing big teams and winning trophies, how about that?

You're comparing Silva to Koeman?

I think you'll find that those who didnt want Koeman wanted Silva...totally opposite sides of the spectrum.

thats fine, wins trophies in his first 2 seasons, third season melt down and then leaves

Great short term thinking here...
 
Mourinho is a manager for the present at any club he has joined. He builds a team that can challenge immediately but very often can sign players at their peak or even beyond, he has to keep replenishing his squad/team as players fall away within a few years of being signed.
We have seen with how he treats players like Martial, Shaw and others that he doesn't trust young relatively inexperienced players.

Silva seems to be the opposite, he signs young players, he plays them and seems prepared to accept the mistakes they can make.
Silva seems to want to build the club with him into the future.... how successful he will be only time will tell.
 

For now we are competing though? I agree that if we start losing every week he needs to park the vision and come up with a way of stopping the rot, but if we can get the results to get us 7th/8th while getting everybody playing the way we want to in the long term, why wouldn't we?
But if we concede for fun we will struggle
Not enough goals in this team to outscore teams
Hopefully Mina and Gomes will add a bit more defensively
 
Mourinho creates tension and life/death mentality like it's a submarine and he captain Nemo..that bursts in season three as we know cause players have enough.. He's record is impressive but not what club in our situation needs
 

The more Silva speaks the more I like him. Seems calm, seems to want the players to get to their best level, isn’t getting caught up in creating silly headlines, just getting on with things quietly. Tough task coming up with Leicester away twice but if we can stay in the cup and get into Christmas in the top half then who knows what might happen.
 
Mourinho is a manager for the present at any club he has joined. He builds a team that can challenge immediately but very often can sign players at their peak or even beyond, he has to keep replenishing his squad/team as players fall away within a few years of being signed.
We have seen with how he treats players like Martial, Shaw and others that he doesn't trust young relatively inexperienced players.

Silva seems to be the opposite, he signs young players, he plays them and seems prepared to accept the mistakes they can make.
Silva seems to want to build the club with him into the future.... how successful he will be only time will tell
.

Interesting thoughts and I agree. Could Silva be wanting to build a dynasty like harry did way back and Howie. TBH if our neighbours had not screwed up, our club could have been well and truly put on the map!
 
My bets would easily be on Mourinho winning another major trophy again before either Everton or Silva do but Silva can go one step towards proving that wrong tonight by us beating Southampton.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top