Fair post. It is refreshing to read a critic of his acknowledging he has done a good job in the past. I know those targets have generally been much lower than what we currently want to achieve, but he has managed them and that shouldn't be ignored in order to backup a pre or ill formed view point, like the vast majority seem to do.
I don't think we are close to breaking top 6 tbh, unless we get 3+ top quality players. I'm fairly sure most would have been satisfied (note: i dont mean pleased) this season if Koeman had managed 7th again, if it had been close to the top 6/4, and not 10-20 points behind them. Because of his mismanagement, DUs inability to stop it, and the boards timewasting & lack of planning, we are a year behind what we wanted to achieve this season, so that is now our minimum aim for the coming season.
I think Allardyce is capable of that, and unless we could entice a proven top manager, I personally wouldn't give that up for a gamble on Silva, Fonseca etc. just for the sake of getting rid of him.
I know the football isnt good. I do think he plays awful, boring football when things are not going well. We'd be upward looking from day 1 next season, not down, so I'd expect a shift in style, with us controlling the ball a lot more yet still based on pragmatic football.
The only other point I'll make is that I don't really ever recall so many blues demanding entertaining football in my lifetime.
We're a side known for industry, not flamboyance. We've loved SOS and Dogs of War. I just feel that the demand for entertainment stems from the desire to be rid of Allardyce more than it does for a want of a different style of football.