You say he's a loser, and he does seem to have become one since leaving Everton, but despite never winning anything at the club, a lot of our fans are short sighted when it comes to his achievements here. Everton were in turmoil before Moyes arrived, relegation battle after relegation battle and the club had turned in to failures long before Moyes arrived at the club. Some of the worst results in my time supporting Everton came just before he got here, like the Tranmere 0-3 in the FA Cup which was an utter humiliation. And then there was the 0-3 in the Quarter Final at Boro which sealed Walter Smith's fate.
Moyes changed all that and turned us from a side expecting to finish 14th-17th each season, to one that was capable of coming 5th-7th. You often hear people using the phrase 'Be careful what you wish for' towards Arsenal fans with Wenger but it turned out to be true with our fanbase too with their ridicule towards Moyes. 'He's taken us as far as he can' they cried lol. In came Martinez and after a great first season we're now in turmoil once again and the one massive influence of the Martinez era has left us for Champions League football and a title challenge. When we are miles away from the top 6 again this season that'll be 4 seasons in a row where we haven't got close to the best finishes Moyes got us.
Moyes got us to a Cup Final, a 4th placed finish and numerous European qualifications. I'd be delighted to just be back where we were under him instead of now being told we have no chance of challenging the likes of Spurs, and should expect to roll over for them when they turn up at Goodison.
I absolutely don't want him back now though, as both parties have moved on.
