James McCarthy

[MACCA75]

Needs to lose this habit of a lazy looking telegraphed pass that he has.

 

[TheOldLady]

Limited player

Need to drop Barry and get a midfielder in who can roam forward and weigh in with a goal or 8

Leave McCarthy as the water carrier

 

[Kiwi]

I think he hasn't played particularly well this season but changed it up after they scored their second and went into a box to box role and was brilliant.

 

[Ihaters]

Liked him again today, a few over ambitious and under performed passes, but mostly, just tidy link up play between defense and attack.

 

[Wat Tyler]

Class ball to kone for fifth

 

[Tubey]

Until the 50th minute I thought he was absolute toilet

Yeah same here. Got better late on but was one of the weaker overall performers.

 

[chicoazul]

He's not arsed as he's got his new contract now.

 

[hetion]

Has played some excellent crosses and long balls forward this season. There were a couple of absolute peaches today that were begging for a finish.

 

[Walken]

He's not arsed as he's got his new contract now.

fair play to him, if he invests that money wisely he could see himself retired back home in scotland before he is 30

 

[Pittsburgh Footy]

Class ball to kone for fifth

I thought it was also a great low ball into Galloway with his left foot prior to that - if Galloway finishes we're talking about how great that goal was. Once he's allowed to come forward more and not worry about covering for Barry, James has shown he can move forward. He will figure it out.

 

[mitchell1996]

Limited player

Need to drop Barry and get a midfielder in who can roam forward and weigh in with a goal or 8

Leave McCarthy as the water carrier

Barkley

 

[TheOldLady]

Barkley

Yer 100%

Need to buy a number 10 though to fill his gap

 

[Robertor]

Thought he was brilliant yesterday. Still think people undervalue him because they don't necessarily understand his role, fans tend to call him limited when his role is to cover the full back, get forward when merited and do Barry's running for him breaking up opposition play. For what his role is in the side I don't think there's many players who could do that better than him.

 

[Charlie Sweet]

Thought he was brilliant yesterday. Still think people undervalue him because they don't necessarily understand his role, fans tend to call him limited when his role is to cover the full back, get forward when merited and do Barry's running for him breaking up opposition play. For what his role is in the side I don't think there's many players who could do that better than him.

Completely agree. He's a great player in my opinion.

 

[streeky]

everyone was raving about his ability to get around the pitch and disrupt play," 2/3rds of the earth is covered by water the rest is covered by James McCarthy" now all of a sudden he is a limited player. Did we really expect him to transform into a Mata or silver when RM bought him.