Tim Howard

kithnou · October 25, 2015

USABlue said:
if you check my post's I said GK needs to get looked at in one of the windows. Just don't think Robles is an improvement. He's been terrible in the cup games.

Didn't read above to be honest. I do agree re keeper. I have said a week ago or so that a top class keeper is our priority next. I would still give Joel a go. Can't be any worse.

mlyons · October 25, 2015

kithnou said:
We won't progress past mid table with him in goal my man. Has to go. Cost us a good 10 goals this season alone.

We've conceded 13 goals in the league so far. Are you seriously suggesting we would have only conceded 3 goals in ten matches with a different keeper?

This is the problem with the discussions of players around here. People can't just make valid criticisms and be happy with them. Everything has to be exaggerated to the point of ridiculousness.

kithnou · October 25, 2015

Kurt said:
howard is a fookin waste of skin, organs,, and goalie gloves

Get off the fence mate. Stop beating around the bush...

kithnou · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
We've conceded 13 goals in the league so far. Are you seriously suggesting we would have only conceded 3 goals in ten matches with a different keeper?

This is the problem with the discussions of players around here. People can't just make valid criticisms and be happy with them. Everything has to be exaggerated to the point of ridiculousness.

ok...a slight exaggeration. I would say half could have been saved by a top keeper. So yes, that equates to at least another 6 points which puts us where??

Elong · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
We've conceded 13 goals in the league so far. Are you seriously suggesting we would have only conceded 3 goals in ten matches with a different keeper?

This is the problem with the discussions of players around here. People can't just make valid criticisms and be happy with them. Everything has to be exaggerated to the point of ridiculousness.

Basic errors have cost us 5-6 goals easily. Yes, he has single handedly cost us points.

mlyons · October 25, 2015

kithnou said:
ok...a slight exaggeration. I would say half could have been saved by a top keeper. So yes, that equates to at least another 6 points which puts us where??

If he had saved half the goals he's conceded, we'd have the best defensive record in the league right now. Which seems unrealistic, given the injuries we've had in our back line.

It's absolutely valid to point out that he's a weak link in the squad, but try to think rationally about it.

kithnou · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
If he had saved half the goals he's conceded, we'd have the best defensive record in the league right now. Which seems unrealistic, given the injuries we've had in our back line.

It's absolutely valid to point out that he's a weak link in the squad, but try to think rationally about it.

c'mon man...he has flapped and conceded a good half dozen. Do the math.

mlyons · October 25, 2015

kithnou said:
c'mon man...he has flapped and conceded a good half dozen. Do the math.

Do the math yourself. Are you saying we would be the best defensive team in the league with a different keeper?

Kurt. · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
If he had saved half the goals he's conceded, we'd have the best defensive record in the league right now. Which seems unrealistic, given the injuries we've had in our back line.

It's absolutely valid to point out that he's a weak link in the squad, but try to think rationally about it.

no it isn't.... he's cost us points... he's woeful, past it, he's become a joke..... I can honestly say it's the first time ive actually hated an Everton player..... I can't stand the fraud and I can't wait until he fooks off outta my club

kithnou · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
Do the math yourself. Are you saying we would be the best defensive team in the league with a different keeper?

Scary where we could be with a top class keeper hey?

Elong · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
Do the math yourself. Are you saying we would be the best defensive team in the league with a different keeper?

Yes.

sageyefc · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
Do the math yourself. Are you saying we would be the best defensive team in the league with a different keeper?

Would be up there

kithnou · October 25, 2015

Kurt said:
no it isn't.... he's cost us points... he's woeful, past it, he's become a joke..... I can honestly say it's the first time ive actually hated an Everton player..... I can't stand the fraud and I can't wait until he fooks off outta my club

That's not necessary.
He has been a top servant of our club. Not his fault he keeps getting a game. He is trying his best.
Let me direct you to the Roberto Martinez thread. He needs your advice as he is bottling it

Bungle · October 25, 2015

mlyons said:
Do the math yourself. Are you saying we would be the best defensive team in the league with a different keeper?

Why is that so inconceivable? Everyone that has stepped up during our injury problems has been solid for the most part.

With a decent keeper we could be in a far better position.

Kurt. · October 25, 2015

kithnou said:
That's not necessary.
He has been a top servant of our club. Not his fault he keeps getting a game. He is trying his best.
Let me direct you to the Roberto Martinez thread. He needs your advice as he is bottling it

He's wank