Who should we get shut of in January

Who should we get shut of in January

  • McGeady

    Votes: 273 89.5%

  • Besic

    Votes: 6 2.0%

  • Gibson

    Votes: 16 5.2%

  • Baines

    Votes: 2 0.7%

  • Stones

    Votes: 8 2.6%
  • Total voters
    305
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pienaar (injury prone)
Mcgeady (Inconsistent)
Gibson (injury prone/on the p*ss)
Hibbert (player is finished/great for brownings progress though)

Only these for now as I don't think they offer the squad anything. Seeing Browning, Galloway and garbutt step up when needed is great to see. Still crying out for a powerhouse to drive us forward, see Veiria, Yaya, Essien (prime) and Gerrard for example.
 
Paul Bernard said:
Pienaar (injury prone)
Mcgeady (Inconsistent)
Gibson (injury prone/on the p*ss)
Hibbert (player is finished/great for brownings progress though)

Only these for now as I don't think they offer the squad anything. Seeing Browning, Galloway and garbutt step up when needed is great to see. Still crying out for a powerhouse to drive us forward, see Veiria, Yaya, Essien (prime) and Gerrard for example.
Click to expand...

Thing is who would want to buy any of those 4?!
 

McGeady and Pienaar.

The latter I would not wish to wave off on poor terms, given some of the moments he has brought us over the last 8 years, not to mention his singular ability to bring the best out of Leighton, but fact is he's ready for the knackers yard now.

I don't bear any ill will against Aiden but fact is it just hasn't happened for him here. Need to get him off the books and stop acting with the heart instead of the head. Not like he needs the money, and we ain't the EPL's answer to Thompson's Mission.

Between the two of them their combined wages would likely cover those of the fabled No.10 we will hopefully bring in over the next 12 months, meaning more wiggle room in the budget to cover the other transfer overheads such a player's arrival will likely spell (transfer fee, agents fees, signing on fees, work permit hearings, cost of a Frube on EZY1846 etc.)
 
Voted McGeady. But if we were to receive 8m for Naismith again, he has to go. Early in the window we must get rid. Plenty of time to find a better more competent replacement, and for cheaper too.
 
Eric Djemba-Djemba said:
Where's the option for that clown in goal?
Click to expand...
Agreed.

I'd ship on Robles. If we are to replace Howard next summer, we must look to bring in a better backup than this shocking keeper. He simply cannot be allowed to take over as Everton's number 1 if we are to challenge for any kind of honours.
 
McGeady definitely.
I would be looking at trying to offload Pienaar and Hibbo immediately if a deal can be done to buy out their contracts and save money. If not, the contracts are up in the summer. Hibbo to coaching staff unless he's moving to France to run his business??
Gibson is probably on his last chance, so I would see what happens between now and Christmas.
Oviedo unlucky with injuries, but I agree that he probably needs to move on for his own benefit. Think his contract is up in the summer.
Would hang on to Besic though.
 

blue4eva77 said:
Agreed.

I'd ship on Robles. If we are to replace Howard next summer, we must look to bring in a better backup than this shocking keeper. He simply cannot be allowed to take over as Everton's number 1 if we are to challenge for any kind of honours.
Click to expand...
Remember when Howard single hamdedly cost us the derby about 4 times. Those were the days.
 
ijjysmith said:
Thing is who would want to buy any of those 4?!
Click to expand...

Well this is were it hits home, probably only the bottom 5 in the league plus championship teams. Gibson is injury prone so its a gamble, mcgeady thinks more of himself then he should. Pienaar could move to a retirement league, good player buy injury prone.
 
hibbo'sclass said:
McGeady definitely.
I would be looking at trying to offload Pienaar and Hibbo immediately if a deal can be done to buy out their contracts and save money. If not, the contracts are up in the summer. Hibbo to coaching staff unless he's moving to France to run his business??
Gibson is probably on his last chance, so I would see what happens between now and Christmas.
Oviedo unlucky with injuries, but I agree that he probably needs to move on for his own benefit. Think his contract is up in the summer.
Would hang on to Besic though.
Click to expand...
Cobbler?
 
Yeah definitely McGeady.

I think Howard, Osman, Gibson and Pienaar are in trouble in the summer as well though. Wouldn't be surprised to see Besic leave either.
 
Tubey said:
Yeah definitely McGeady.

I think Howard, Osman, Gibson and Pienaar are in trouble in the summer as well though. Wouldn't be surprised to see Besic leave either.
Click to expand...
Why Besic mate? He's the natural understudy to Barry, who isn't likely to remain here forever himself.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top