James McCarthy - Signed on deadline day for reported £13m

Status
Not open for further replies.
Paying anywhere near 10m (never mind over it) is an absolute joke and Dave Whelan is probably laughing himself silly to the bank.
For balance (because we all know that rule number 1 of this forum is that no negativity is allowed whatsoever no matter how justified) i would be more than happy to pay 3-5m and replace Osman with him.

You logged into the wrong site mate ?
 

very ropey form previous to this including a 1 in 40 for Sevilla....

What people are ignoring about Kone is in his 5 years at Sevilla he was loaned out twice and his 40 appearances were not all starts and came staggered between his loan spells. He has scored goals at PSV, Levante and Roda and is a good finisher. I have faith in Kone. This is a player that has scored goals to beat Real Madrid. People using the Kone signing to attack Martinez are being childish.
 
Orly:




...any chance mate?

'Delighted' is the word you used....


...what would delight you about McCarthy's arrival?

You show me where you got our 9m bid for Barry Ferguson, I'd be delighted to tell you why I'd have Osman out for McCarthy.
 
What?!?!

Fellaini for us has 9, 3, 3, 5, 12 for us

Compare that to McCarthy and Osman.

So we should criticise that he was flexible enough to play in another position for us when we needed goals? Totally stupid.

Full of fail, yes, your logic is.

...so why would you be 'delighted' if he arrived, Orly?
 
It means he's on the move all the time. Which he is.

I noticed above you said you'd be happy with McCarthy if it wasn't a straight 'swap' for fellaini.

Can you tell us, then, what his qualities are that you'd see him bringing to us?

Are you answering this one Orly or just coming out with more verbal diarrhea?
 

McCarthy will be Martinez's first big signing. Him and Barkley and Gibson will keep us strong in CM, an area people are calling on us to improve. Barkley is 19 and McCarthy is 23 in November. I like others hope we don't invest £15m because I don't see his price going up. I think Wigan are bluffing and we should make a final offer that is on our terms. Whelan is playing hard-ball but will let him leave like he let Martinez leave.
 
You show me where you got our 9m bid for Barry Ferguson, I'd be delighted to tell you why I'd have Osman out for McCarthy.

I was mistaken mate. Honestly.

Your turn: what about McCarthy turning up at Everton would you be happy with as you said earlier? What qualities does he bring to the table etc?
 
What people are ignoring about Kone is in his 5 years at Sevilla he was loaned out twice and his 40 appearances were not all starts and came staggered between his loan spells. He has scored goals at PSV, Levante and Roda and is a good finisher. I have faith in Kone. This is a player that has scored goals to beat Real Madrid. People using the Kone signing to attack Martinez are being childish.

You don't need to insult others who share different opinion. In this sense, I think blind optimism on Martinez's signings is naive.
 
I will make up my mind about this (potential) signing when he has donned the royal blue officially and has played a couple of months for us. I just wish we were looking for a decent forward as we don't have any.

However, Del is wide of the mark with regards to the odour of ginger urine. White asparagus wrapped in bacon is more accurate.
 

I was mistaken mate. Honestly.

Your turn: what about McCarthy turning up at Everton would you be happy with as you said earlier? What qualities does he bring to the table etc?

Are we clear this would be versus Osman, and not Fellaini?
 
I was talking about league goals 8,2,1,3 hardly great is it, Shock horror he scored 11 last season as a forward

McCarthy since joining Wigan 1,3,3 hardly any difference when they play as a DM is there

Yes he can play in two postions but the fact is he wants out and has asked to leave, McCarthy's stats are not bad in fact for his postion they are good, You bring goals into it when we all know the reason he got 11 last year is because he played as a forward
 
2.5 million for mcmanaman though?

tumblr_m6v2l9UW0n1ranhnao1_500.gif
 
What people are ignoring about Kone is in his 5 years at Sevilla he was loaned out twice and his 40 appearances were not all starts and came staggered between his loan spells. He has scored goals at PSV, Levante and Roda and is a good finisher. I have faith in Kone. This is a player that has scored goals to beat Real Madrid. People using the Kone signing to attack Martinez are being childish.

No matter how his appearances came, he got on the pitch 40 times and scored once.

Oh and Ji Dong Won has scored to beat City.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top