2024/25 James Garner

[murphy89]

Just got back from the game. I thought Garner was really good. Weird how we all see it differently

 

[EGWToffee]

Gets stuck in his slide tackles are proper Everton

 

[Lanolin]

Didn't see this at all. He was better than gana today, and he got the move going for our second goal.

He was better than gana but it was still a very nothing performance. The midfield was wide open whenever they broke and we never had any sort of control with the ball.

 

[DanEFC92]

QUOTE="EFCINLONDON, post: 12024034, member: 15100"]
Didn't see this at all. He was better than gana today, and he got the move going for our second goal.

Getting alot of stick based on not closing down Enciso for a wondergoal.

Clearly better than Gana and id say 7/10 today. Hes just a 6 or 7 player each game.

We will upgrade him with Armstrong and need a big upgrade on Gana soon too.

Garner will be a good long term squad player.
[/QUOTE]

What did he do to warrant a 7/10

 

[Frenk]

He’s ok but never a starter next season. Squad player at best.

 

[YoboCopter]

Thought he was boss at first but hasnt played out that way has it

 

[Eggs]

Thought he was boss at first but hasnt played out that way has it

…thought he played well first half too but maybe should’ve closed their goalscorer down before half-time.

 

[YoboCopter]

…thought he played well first half too but maybe should’ve closed their goalscorer down before half-time.

not this game tbh just in his general time here

 

[JimmyJeffers]

Clearly better than Gana

I like Garner but lol

 

[Walken]

Played well, he's a good player we should retain

 

[mikel_88]

Just got back from the game. I thought Garner was really good. Weird how we all see it differently

Same but as always i still want more from him thought again alot of his best work was the defensive part. Did alot of covering first and second half, just dont think we have a link in midfield to get it to the attacking three.

 

[Walken]

Just got back from the game. I thought Garner was really good. Weird how we all see it differently

He's the whipping boy for the lads who don't really understand midfield

 

[brucemate]

Same but as always i still want more from him thought again alot of his best work was the defensive part. Did alot of covering first and second half, just dont think we have a link in midfield to get it to the attacking three.

Agree, works hard like Gana(not as good) but not rarely seems to create supply to our attackers. I think a new centre mid with vision is one of our several priorities.

 

[Miked1e]

Good squad player…. But we need much better.

Not sure what he actually offers.

 

[davids]

He's the whipping boy for the lads who don't really understand midfield

Seems to have recovered from his back injury which is a plus. In midfield we have a few players who've had fairly long term injuries so maybe unfair to judge them to harshly before they have a full pre-season before Bramley Moor.