Why does it matter what I think? What point are you trying to prove?
A points deduction is not a fair punishment. It’s totally ridiculous.
pfim
Player Valuation: £35m
Agreed
Im not trying to prove any point, I was honestly just curious what other people feel is a "fair" punishment.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
This text, in my opinion, is setting out that this case will not set a precedent and that all future cases will be treated and punished/unpunished on their own merit. It gives the ability for any other gathering to come to a completely different conclusion, with no boundary of range.
There is no fixed formula to be applied: we are required to determine the extent of the culpability, and from that to determine the points deduction. That requires the exercise of our discretion as a specialist panel, and a determination to be made based on all the facts of the case.
Clearly you feel a points deduction is a fair punishment, which is laughable. But then you also think DCL is an elite forward who would be of interest to any serious football club.
Make the rules fair to start with .
That would be a start . We squandered money absolutely. But it's not a level playing field at all.
I dont think a fine or a Transfer ban would act as a deterrent.
In the EFL they take points, so thus a points removal would be a fair punishment.
Given the mitigation and our frugal spending, I would be wanting it suspended.
But no problem.
pfim
Player Valuation: £35m
Watching a Michael Keane blooper real on a continuous loop.
On what planet is a transfer ban not a deterrent?!?
Well for Everton, in Summer 2024, it would finish us off.
So I assume you think a transfer ban is a fair punishment?
Whats stopping somebody from spending 2billion on players knowing they would only get a transfer ban.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
A window for every £10m over.
Know ‐ we will know the outcome of our first breach on the points deducted soon .
I think a transfer ban would’ve been a hell of a lot fairer than a TEN POINT DEDUCTION. Transfers are actually relevant to club finances. Having said that, not being able to buy a striker who’s familiar with a goal net in the summer and having to watch DCL flounder about trying to score a goal again next season scares me more than any points deduction.
I dont want a 10 point deduction.
And we might wanna consider creating chances for our Striker if we want him to score, but thats for another thread.
