Your 5 favourite Everton players during Premier League

[Papa Shango]

Kevin Campbell
Graham Stuart
Olivier Dacourt
Richard Gough
Oumar Niasse

 

[BornBlue76]

Arteta - Everton's best player since the 80's!
Yakubu - most natural finisher and incredibly likeable... misused by Moyes in the end.
Barkley - under appreciated and massively missed.
Manny Fernandes - we were one of the most aesthetically pleasing teams when he was with us. What a partnership he and Arteta made!
Lukaku - hard to include a player who doesn't love the club but he was easily our best player during his time with us either way.

Special mention for Saha. What a player he could have been but riddled by injury. Have never seen a a better player in our shirt when surrounded by 4 opposition and able to get out with the ball.

 

[Agent Blue]

Kanchelskis
Beardo
Martyn
Cahill
Gravesen

 

[Nyhus]

Coleman
Arteta
Lukaku
Distin
Baines

 

[Marius57]

1. Dunc
2. Hibbert
3. Cahill
4. Coleman
5. Gravesen.

In that order.

Shoutouts to Niasse, Wessels, Fellaini, Strac and Tie. Have a soft spot for all of them.

 

[paul11]

Kanchelskis
Speed
Arteta
Cahill
Ferguson

 

[Bluebonic]

Campbell, Kanchelskis, Cahill, Southall, Coleman

 

[IveGotThe]

Gough
Cahill
Arteta
Pienaar
Yakubu

 

[Raino85]

Baines
Arteta
Cahill
Ferguson
Pienaar

 

[Groucho]

Criteria is PL games for us.

Southall - obviously
Lukaku - could not exclude due to his talent and 4 year stay
Pienaar - along with Baines and Jags, deserved a trophy with us in 2009, that was a good team 07 to 09
Kanchelskis - probably the only one in recent times who could've walked in to the 85 side
Ferguson - wasted his talent in some ways but was a figurehead in hard times

 

[Markydys]

Great question...

Dunc
Southall
(Both should be on everyone’s list)

And then
Cahill
Coleman
Graveson

 

[PhilM]

Arteta - Everton's best player since the 80's!

While I fully agree that Arteta was a fantastic player, what about Kanchelskis?

A tricky question to be fair but for me I've gone with:
- Kanchelskis,
- Kevin Campbell,
- Southall,
- Cahill,
- Watson.

Ferguson, Arteta, Carsley, Coleman, Baines and Pienaar are all close calls.

 

[marmor]

Cahill
Coleman
Parkinson
Arteta
Baines

 

[bullybeef]

Kanchelskis
Limpar
Graveson
Cahill
Martyn

 

[bullybeef]

Beardsley - first reserve
Madar - second reserve