Worst Everton signing

[Khalekan]

Hard to look beyond Nyarko and McGeady. Alcaraz was woeful too. I would say that Beattie was better than all of them (but not by a great deal).

This must be an age thing.....the four mentioned wouldn't make the top twenty of the worst Everton players those of us watching since the 70s have seen

(Well, Alcaraz might )


Brett Angell, Claus Thomson, Mitch Ward, Mark Pemberton, Mike Milliken, John Oster......now there names to conjure with

And of a more recent vintage, Ibn Tal, Abel Xavier and Jo must come close to making the cut

 

[BlueToff]

Christ you bore me.

Ginola and McGeady are mine and you're not telling me any different.

Why is having a different opinion boring?

Surely that's what a forum's for?

 

[Khalekan]

Ian Wilson

Close the thread.....we have a winner

 

[Donald Twain]

This Iranian bloke has potential

 

[ianefc]

Why is having a different opinion boring?

Surely that's what a forum's for?

Yep fair enough.

 

[larbert toffee]

McGeady for me and David Johnson second time round,as for Tiger Mclaughlin he just retired from plumbing up here in Scotland a couple of years ago, after his spell with Everton he went to the states to ply his trade and quite smartly at some point swapped his shirt with Pele, it now hangs proudly in the Victoria pub, Carronshore and will earn him a nice couple of boob when he comes to sell it.

 

[nsno-chris]

Brett Angell; so far out of his depth it was scary

And Ian Wilson, turbo gash on all levels

 

[Bluebonic]

Geoff Nulty was pretty gash! jim Pearson was the footballing equivalent of toothache and george telfer, simply becaus ehe should have been great and he was anything but!

 

[Tree13]

This must be an age thing.....the four mentioned wouldn't make the top twenty of the worst Everton players those of us watching since the 70s have seen

(Well, Alcaraz might )


Brett Angell, Claus Thomson, Mitch Ward, Mark Pemberton, Mike Milliken, John Oster......now there names to conjure with

And of a more recent vintage, Ibn Tal, Abel Xavier and Jo must come close to making the cut

Fair point! Having said that, I've been watching since '83 and I'd disagree with you on several of those you listed. All underwhelming, sure... well actually I'd say Xavier was okay.

Angel, Thomson, Ward, Oster all put shifts in, which is more than can ever be said for Nyarko, McGeady and Alcaraz.

 

[Angel of Brett]

Geoff Nulty was pretty gash! jim Pearson was the footballing equivalent of toothache and george telfer, simply becaus ehe should have been great and he was anything but!

Nulty used to wander around the pitch like lost child, he was woeful. Joe Harper is another who could be in the frame too.

 

[COYBL25]

Bilic and Danny Williamson.

These two for their total lack of being arsed,combined wages and transfer fees.

 

[Alanbileysfeathercut]

Nulty used to wander around the pitch like lost child, he was woeful. Joe Harper is another who could be in the frame too.

Leave joe alone he always speaks fondly of Everton if you see him he'll stop and speak about us .as has been said before once Everton touches you.......

 

[Bluerocket]

Sorry guys, this crown is definetly and firmly on Rod Belfits from Ipswich. I think David Johnson went he other way as part of the deal.

 

[Angel of Brett]

Leave joe alone he always speaks fondly of Everton if you see him he'll stop and speak about us .as has been said before once Everton touches you.......

He just couldn't adjust his game to the 1st Div, nice to see former players still touched by the blues all these years later.

 

[jaycee]

Bellfit, Bernie Wright, Brett Angell three forwards that terrified more than the Barcelona trio