Worst Everton player in Moyes' Era

[tsdoddy]

Genuinely shocked by the amount of stick Naismith gets on here.

why?????? :blink:

 

[grandjoeblue]

I went for the only player on that list I don't remember...

Kevin McLeod

...seriously...who the frak was Kevin McLeod? I even remember the likes of Li Wei Fang, Idan Tal & Juliano Rodrigo, who must have played about 12 first-team minutes between them...but Kevin McLeod? Never even heard of him.


EDIT: I just googled him, and it seems he played 5 games for us during the latter-part of the Walter Smith era. I have to admit, in 24 years of bluedom, the only period I wained (as in not actively following every game) was during the last couple of Walter Smith years. Combination of utter boredom at our football and utter exciting life as I discovered pilled-up raving was the reason for that.

So yeah...that's my defence why I've never heard of Kevin McLeod.

He was an alright young player McLeod, slightly out of his depth at the time though.

I don't see why people have in issue with a thread on the 'worst players', if anything some of these players have basically ripped our club off by taking our money (Van Der Meyde, Nyarko).

 

[Rook]

No option for Mirallas's hamstring?

I voted for Davies because I forgot about Krodulp. Davies deserves more of a mention though, I'm not sure if it was 0 times or just 1-2 times that we got 3 pts in matches he started. He was turrible, not sure why we didn't get the player Fulham got.

Niasmith 2nd worst? LOL, please. Last I checked he's was always signed as a backup, has played out of position and still managed to grab a few goals for us.

Its funny because the press that I read on Krodulp and ADV when they were signed were extremely positive. Then we found out in training that Krodulp didn't know how to head the ball.

Jo is legend, if you voted for him you are going to hell.

 

[hktoffee]

From the list above - it got to be Kevin McLeod. He is playing non-league football now. Unsuccessful career.

 

[Neiler]

I seem to remember Scott Gemill and Mark Pembridge playing under Moyes.

Eddie Bosnar deserves a mntion.

 

[jtl60]

Can the people who voted for Li Tie tell me there thought process when making their decision?
He was a cracking player in his first season and was the victim of a terrible broken leg that he never really recovered from.

 

[Neiler]

Can the people who voted for Li Tie tell me there thought process when making their decision?
He was a cracking player in his first season and was the victim of a terrible broken leg that he never really recovered from.

Liked Lie Tie myself. Wouldnt get anywhere near us now but at the time he did a great job for us.

Its interesting seeing peoples reaction now to some of those players, though you have to view it at the context of the time many were a step up for us. Though again wouldnt get near us now. How far we have come, how far we could possibly fall - nothing has really changed financially since the days Joseph Yobo was considered Pele and there was Strokes all round untill we signed him on a permo, mass Weir and Stubbs out threads as well.

Brian McBride was the mammary Glands by the way!

 

[jtl60]

Liked Lie Tie myself. Wouldnt get anywhere near us now but at the time he did a great job for us.

Agreed, but worst ever? Someones having a laugh - he played alongside the likes of Pembridge, Gemmil and Alexanderson, he was 10 times the players any of those mugs were

 

[Neiler]

Agreed, but worst ever? Someones having a laugh - he played alongside the likes of Pembridge, Gemmil and Alexanderson, he was 10 times the players any of those mugs were

They werent the best mate, in fact they were awful but Gemo and Pembo gave it there limited all. Alexanderson used to leave me furious - half hearted to say the least

 

[Chang Elephant]

No problem debating worst player - voted Simon Davies btw, can see why he's on the list twice. But why are the following players anywhere near this list ?

Francis Jeffers
Li Tie
Tomasz Radzinski
Joseph Yobo
Joe-Max Moore
Brian McBride
Marcus Bent
Nuno Valente
Segundo Castillo
Lucas Neill
Dan Gosling
James Vaughan
Diniya Bilyaletdinov
Aiyegbeni Yakubu
Jose Baxter
Phil Neville
Victor Anichebe

 

[kjb1994]

where is Richard Wright ? my great nan could of saved better than her and shes dead