Who is your Everton XI from the Premier League era?

[nsno-chris]

Southall

Kanchelskis x10

 

[GwladysBlue]

No Gary Naismith?

Pistone was a lot worse.

 

[Bluecranks]

Wright
Hibbert Koldrup Williams Pistone
Gemmil Castillo Neville Alexanderson
Anichibe Straq

How to give a question ending with "from the Premier League era" the respect it deserves. That is, none. Good man.

 

[Verbal Kint]

Martyn

Coleman
Jagielka
Lescott
Baines

Arteta
Gana
Cahill
Kanchelskis

Rooney
Lukaku


That, is a Team.

Yeah that will save me the hassle of typing. Perhaps id have Campbell ahead of Rooney in the only change.

 

[LydiateLee]

Martyn

Coleman....Watson...Jagielka....Baines

Kanchelskis...Arteta...Cahill.....Pienaar

...........Yakubu.....Lukaku

 

[bicycleheader]

just personal preference like, not saying its the best

Southall
Coleman Stones D.Watson Baines
Arteta Gravesen
Kanchelskis Pienaar
Lukaku Cahill

Honorable mentions: Martyn Ferguson Jags Yakubu Barkley Carsley Parkinson Fellaini Speed Weir Gana

 

[Debunkology]

--------------------- Southall
---------------------
Coleman ------- Watson ------ Lescott ----- Baines
---------------------
--------------------- Gueye
Kanchelski ---------Arteta------------------- Limpar
---------------------
---------------------Cahill
---------------------Ferguson

Subs: Martyn, Weir, Carsley, Speed, Lukaku

 

[Papa Shango]

GK Neville Southall

LB Andy Hinchcliffe
CB Joseph Yobo
CB Dave Watson
RB Seamus Coleman

LM Steven Pienaar
CM Joe Parkinson
CM Mikel Arteta
RM Andrei Kanchelskis

CM Tim Cahill

ST Romelu Lukaku

Subs/ Honourable mentions

Leighton Baines (Who should pair up with Pienaar really but I love Hinchcliffe)
Phil Jagielka
Nigel Martyn
Kevin Campbell
Graham Stuart (Without these two we would have far less seasons to choose from..)
Gary Speed
Peter Beardsley

 

[The T-Dex]

Premier League era...

Howard

Coleman Jagielka Lescott Baines

Kanchelskis Arteta Fellaini Pienaar

Cahill

Lukaku

Actually a bannable offense having him in goal.

 

[Brendan Janus]

Southall
Coleman, Watson, Lescott, Baines
Kanchelskis, Cahill, Speed, Pienaar
Beardsley, Lukaku

Subs:
Martyn, Distin, Arteta, Gravesen, I.Gueye, Rooney, Ferguson

Too many midfielders I guess. Bit like Ronald. Probs forgot a hundred or so players.

Beardsley was simply magic for us for two seasons !!

 

[Azzurri]

From 2004ish, as that's about the earliest I can properly remember:

Martyn

Coleman -- Jagielka -- Lescott -- Baines

Arteta -- Cahill -- Gueye -- Pienaar

Rooney -- Lukaku
​

Subs:
Pickford
Yobo
Fellaini
Carsley
Mirallas
Saha
Yakubu

 

[yakublue]

Southall
Coleman Jagielka Watson Baines
Carsley
Arteta Gravesen Cahill Kancheskis
Lukaku​

 

[Kev The Rat]

Southall
Coleman Lescott Jagielka Baines
Kanchelskis Hutchison Barmby Speed
Rooney Lukaku

Barmby was the worst Judas imaginable, but at his peak a class player for us.

The likes of Hutch, Barmby and Speed suffer in comparison to later players due to them being in poor Walter/HK mk3 sides, but I suspect they had a lot more quality than most who played under Moyes.

 

[Kurt.]

Comparing Howard to Southall is like comparing @chicoazul 'S Mar To Claudia schiffer

Obviously I meant schiffer is a pig
@chicoazul

 

[Kurt.]

Southall
Coleman Lescott Jagielka Baines
Kanchelskis Hutchison Barmby Speed
Rooney Lukaku

Barmby was the worst Judas imaginable, but at his peak a class player for us.

The likes of Hutch, Barmby and Speed suffer in comparison to later players due to them being in poor Walter/HK mk3 sides, but I suspect they had a lot more quality than most who played under Moyes.

I'd have Gary speed over cahill every time tbh