Who is your Everton XI from the Premier League era?

[Black Belt Jones]

If you're picking Beardsley then you have to also pick Keown IMHO [believe he just scrapes into the prem era in the RBJ]. Superb players who were great for Everton, but their career peaks were at other clubs.

 

[Boss_Blue]

Southall

Coleman - Watson - Lescott - Baines

Kanchelskis - Arteta - Gueye - Pienaar

Rooney - Lukaku

Bench:

Martyn
Jagielka
Gravesen
Parkinson
Cahill
Ferguson

 

[mckenziemagic]

Imagine this team if they had played for us at their peak:

Westerveld
Barrett Bilic Gough Sansom
Van de Meyde Gascoigne Blomquist Ginola
E'to Mark Hughes

But seriously:

Southall
Snodin Keown Distin Baines
Kanchelskis Hutchison Gueye Pienaar
Rooney Beardsley

(Bench: Martyn, Lescott, Neville, Saha, Big Dunc, Tim Cahill, Donovan)

 

[Azzurri]

Any team without Baines and Pienaar down the left is simply wrong.

 

[Azzurri]

Southall
Coleman Jagielka Watson Baines
Dacourt Arteta
Kanchelskis Rooney Deulofeu
Lukaku
​

Wanted to include Big Dunc, Joe Parkinson, Gravesen and Fellaini but just couldn't squeeze them in. That eleven pisses the top 4 and probably challenges for the league.

​

Wait what

 

[Hibbo]

Wright
Hibbert Koldrup Williams Pistone
Gemmil Castillo Neville Alexanderson
Anichibe Straq

This is a good team

 

[SpeedEFC]

Wright

Jacobsen Kroldrup Alcaraz Pistone

Van Der Meyde Heitinga Neville Bilyaletdinov

Angell Jo
​

It'd break Derby County's record imo.

 

[Walken]

Imagine this team if they had played for us at their peak:

Westerveld
Barrett Bilic Gough Sansom
Van de Meyde Gascoigne Blomquist Ginola
E'to Mark Hughes

But seriously:

Southall
Snodin Keown Distin Baines
Kanchelskis Hutchison Gueye Pienaar
Rooney Beardsley

(Bench: Martyn, Lescott, Neville, Saha, Big Dunc, Tim Cahill, Donovan)

Picking gough in a joke team? He was top class

 

[woomy]

Martyn
Jags Keane Lescott
Coleman Baines
Arteta Carsley
Kanchelskis Rooney
Ferguson

I think a Baines and Rooney partnership would have been a thing of wonder to see. Big dunc winning those headers for Rooney and Kanchelskis. Chucking Keane in as I reckon he will be a fantastic player for us.

 

[Goat]

Southall
Martina - Jags - Lescott - Baines
Besic - Morgan
Kanchelskis - Rooney - Arteta
Ferguson​

 

[mckenziemagic]

Picking gough in a joke team? He was top class

Yes Goughie was top class but he was 35 when he joined us, and that was the point I was making with that team. I'm sure he was a better player when he was around 28-30.

 

[Khalekan]

Neville

Seamus, Unsie, Jags, Baines

Deulefou, Arteta, Gana, Peinaar

Wayne, Lukaku

Subs: Martyn, Kanchelskis, Dave Watson, Parkinson, Big Dunc, Stuart, Hinchcliffe

 

[sladen90]

Martyn
Baines. Stubbs (love the bloke) Watson Coleman
Gravesen carsley arteta
Cahill
Big dunc rooney/lukaku i cant choose

 

[sladen90]

Anyone putting Martyn ahead of Southall needs to have a word with themselves. Martyn was good but at his best he still wasn't fit to lace Big Nev's boots. Southall won us our last trophy.

Southall only played 2 years longer than Martyn thought in regards to the question.

 

[barneygumble]

Would have to go along the lines of


Martyn

Baines
Lescott
Jagielka
Coleman

Parkinson
Kanchelskis
Speed
Arteta

Ferguson
Lukaku

Honourable shouts to Hinchcliffe, Limpar, Campbell, Rooney, Pienaar, Cahill, Watson and probably about 20 others