Which 'Phil' was the better Everton skipper?

[roy vernon]

Jags was a good player but a poor skipper. Nev was the same but without the good player bit.

 

[FTY]

Might just be me but I find it a bit embarrassing that this goal is still celebrated so much. We scored in the last minute to draw against Liverpool but you’d think it was the winner in the FA Cup final the way people still go on about it.

Not havin that mate

Combo of quality of the strike, time in the game, opposition and who scored it

Take any 1 of those 4 out (including the fact it was against them) and it'd still be a big moment because of the other 3

 

[captainvindaloo]

They were captains?
Neville was louder and more aggressive on the pitch than Jags, not sure if that makes him the better captain. Both were decent players at their peak, but became an embarrassment in their latter years. Captains are only really remembered for their triumphs and successes, which means neither will ever equal the likes of Kev and Brian.

 

[Azzurri]

Both as bad as each other really, Neville because he was a bad tit who thought we were a no mark club, Jagielka because he’s a mute.

Voted Jagielka because Phil Neville was 36 years old with spikey blonde highlights.

 

[Azzurri]

Might just be me but I find it a bit embarrassing that this goal is still celebrated so much. We scored in the last minute to draw against Liverpool but you’d think it was the winner in the FA Cup final the way people still go on about it.

One of your most subtle for a while this. Working on your craft I see.

 

[captainvindaloo]

Both as bad as each other really, Neville because he was a bad tit who thought we were a no mark club, Jagielka because he’s a mute.

Voted Jagielka because Phil Neville was 36 years old with spikey blonde highlights.

Horrifying