toffeejack
Player Valuation: £100m
all a bit odd

I think there's a general misconception here. I'm not sure that many people actually want him to re sign, but are wishing we had a player like Cahill was in his prime.
IMHO, Everton is missing a bit of mongrel on the paddock. Tim was the last one to embody that physicality. I'd love to see him back, but only in a coaching or mentoring role.
Depends on what the offer was. Could have been to be a depth player with an impact role off the bench when needed followed by a coaching role. Guess we will never know!