Probably so. He'd be the only QB to win 2 super bowls and not get in if not.
The NFL Thread, 2019
- Thread starter SerenityNigh
- Start date
- Status
Probably so. He'd be the only QB to win 2 super bowls and not get in if not.
Modern day Jim Plunkett.
Might get in, but definitely doesn't deserve it. Bang average.
Separate conversation, where do those Pats go in list of best NFL teams last 40 years? I can think of 85 Bears as another team on that level. Probably also the 89 (?) Niners and one of the Cowboys teams (though they all merge together for me). The Greatest Show on Turf was fun, but they are probably top ten at best. For me those are maybe the 4 best teams I've seen play.
Plunkett ain't in and should never be. He won two.
Question for the group: If Eli hadn’t refused to go to San Diego, does he win a title there? Does Rivers win one for the Giants?
Toast
Player Valuation: £80m
As I'm the only one who seems to like Rivers, I will say yes !!
carlos21
KING OF REP
Hello mate how are you doing today buddy how is your dog.
Good mate, he's growing big. He's way bigger than my last picture but I'll put it in your thread.
carlos21
KING OF REP
Thank you buddy.
Well seeing as how Rivers is a much better QB than Eli I reckon he wins about two. Eli none.
Rivers had a lot of talent on those Chargers teams... I can't see him as more than an average QB in the big passing offense era. He's more Matthew Stafford or Andy Dalton than Dan Fouts, that's certain.
Rivers has better stats across the board passing the ball (like every single category) and has a better W-L record.
I guess this to me is the essence of the conversation. We can't really tell if Rivers or Eli is better, but Eli won 2 rings. So Eli will probably get in the Hall, but Rivers was simply average. And Eli was average too.
For me Rivers is miles better, and Eli should never get in. Just like Plunkett never should. Stabler never should have either.
- Status