But why put forward names of strikers the manager has no intention of signing
If there was 6/7 target man strikers mentions and their merits and faults discussed then great
It's like the VVD thread , why bother it's never going to happen
I'd love it happen but it won't.
As to the Martins and Kenny situation I agree we can and discuss it because both those players are st the club
The same with DCL and possibly Siggy
But why discuss players the club have no intention of signing
Well firstly, unless you've had one of those pints with Koeman that you're fond of mentioning, you've no idea whether we'd be interested in certain players or not have you? I mean, reports have suggested that our back up plan to Sigurdsson is Seri, who is a totally different type of player. Similarly last year we seemingly looked at Mata and Witsel for a long time before plumping for a move for Sissoko, again a totally different player. It seems possible then, that we may have interest in different types of forwards if we can't get our first choice.
Secondly, I don't see any difference in the examples you use. Us talking about these things doesn't change what is going to happen in reality, so why bother giving opinions at all? People aren't 'putting forward' names in the hope that Steve Walsh will log on and go 'YES! Why didn't I think of that!', they're just giving their thoughts on who they'd like to see in the side, same as people are doing with the other topics.