Dave is right to suggest that Baines is not the player he was....he has not been at his best or even close to it since his injury, and seems to be going through the motions, staying out of trouble most of the time. He was never a great defender, and never was able to stop crosses coming in to our area from the opposing right wing, his best attribute was always his attacking flair. His attacking capability has deteriorated along with the loss of pace...he dare not venture too often upfield because he gets stranded. I think he'll be first choice this season if he stays fit, but it may well be his last as our primary left back. If by January it looks like Baines is a weak link, we may well be in the market for a replacement, or stiff competion for Leighton,who in any event has had a superb career.