Steven Pienaar

Carlito · January 25, 2015

Most underrated Everton player of my lifetime. I hope the balloons that never rated him have realised how much we've missed him this season.

I also think he's been written off too quickly.

Vaughan · January 25, 2015

great player but he's finished. if we can put his wages towards a replacement i'll be happy

GrandOldTeam · January 25, 2015

He is finished for any club that genuinely has ambitions to compete anywhere near the top. His legs are gone.

Whenever he gets the ball now he runs himself into the ground.

We need better.

tim cahill · January 25, 2015

Carlito said:
Most underrated Everton player of my lifetime. I hope the balloons that never rated him have realised how much we've missed him this season.

I also think he's been written off too quickly.

I don't think he's been under rated at all. He's been one of our most creative players since he's been here.

He's barely contributed at all in 18 months though so getting him off the wage bill would help us fund a replacement that can help the team.

TheFinnFan · January 25, 2015

GrandOldTeam said:
He is finished for any club that genuinely has ambitions to compete anywhere near the top. His legs are gone.

Whenever he gets the ball now he runs himself into the ground.

We need better.

that was massively embarassing...it pretty much happened in every game, several times even..

Carlito · January 25, 2015

tim cahill said:
I don't think he's been under rated at all. He's been one of our most creative players since he's been here.

He's barely contributed at all in 18 months though so getting him off the wage bill would help us fund a replacement that can help the team.

He was still quality when he played last season.

I'm all for upgrading the team at every opportunity, but I very much doubt Pienaar will be replaced if he moves in this window.

mrb85 · January 25, 2015

GrandOldTeam said:
He is finished for any club that genuinely has ambitions to compete anywhere near the top. His legs are gone.

Whenever he gets the ball now he runs himself into the ground.

We need better.

But you're forgetting that our ambitions presently rest purely on staying in the Division. And to meet this most critical of goals it's vital that we retain every possible option to our line up.

tim cahill · January 25, 2015

Carlito said:
He was still quality when he played last season.

I'm all for upgrading the team at every opportunity, but I very much doubt Pienaar will be replaced if he moves in this window.

I thought he was poor compared to his usual standards to be honest.

kenada_blue · January 25, 2015

Still top in assists from midfield this season.....

TrixyStevens · January 25, 2015

No speed, no anticipation. His control seems to have disappeared aswell. Would rather have Osman in there linking up with baines. Time to move on. Perisic would be so good

Arteta2391 · January 25, 2015

There is something about Everton players losing their swag when their long hair is gone...

diggerdestroyer · January 25, 2015

Baines and himself were a great combo couple seasons ago. Probably best days are gone. Wouldn't be in my starting 11. Don't think I'd be bringing him on either

kenada_blue · January 25, 2015

He's not really played enough to say he's done for me.

Eric Djemba-Djemba · January 25, 2015

tim cahill said:
I thought he was poor compared to his usual standards to be honest.

He was poor. Last season all he did was slow the play down and spend the rest of the game on his arse. We looked like a better team without him.

This season we've been crap without him but not because we're without him specifically. Just a player like him. These days he's finished and we should be looking at getting rid of him as soon as possible.