CahillsCornerFlag
Player Valuation: £70m
I mostly agree but I think it's also true that really prolific goalscorers aren't as important to great teams as you'd think. If you look at the great teams and the great goalscorers there's a lot less overlap then you'd expect and often the most prolific strikers don't win that many trophies.
The five best english strikers in terms of top flight goals are Hodgson, Bloomer, Shearer, Dean and Greaves. Bloomer and Hodgson never won anything despite scoring hatfulls while Shearer and Greaves both joined already great teams (the spurs double winners and Keegan's newcastle) and if anything made them worse rather than kicking up to the next level.
The year Kendall's Everton had Lineker was the year we won nothing, the van nistelrooy years are by far Man Utd's least successful of recent times. A truly great team is one that's set up to create oppurtunities (so the current newcastle team has always managed to create a lot of goals for whoever was in the central role, whether that's Cisse, Ba or even Carroll or the way nobodies liked Rebrov, Laslandes and Marlet have scored lots when playing truly great teams and then crashed and burned once sold on) and a pure poacher can often interfere with that system while still scoring enough goals to not be dropped.
I love how you just nailed the 3 strikers I use as examples of complete flops. Occasionally Flo gets referenced for his Sunderland era.