Should we go for Silva?

edge · January 21, 2018

Didn't want him , before big Sam don't want him after him either.

Muppet Basher · January 21, 2018

no not from me

Eggs · January 21, 2018

..let’s just have them both.

Toffeelover · January 21, 2018

LiamG said:
Chelsea are another club that change their managers regularly. It does them no harm.

Part of the game now which is why we moved to a DOF.

They can afford it.

Gwladysstreetlad · January 21, 2018

For the love of god no! Why cant some of you see that Silva is yet another flavour of mouth manager who has achieved absolutely nothing of significance and would be another disastrous appointment for us. Half of you only want him because your so blinded by hatred for Allardyce that you cant see that its better to be stuck with BFS till the end of the season then with Silva for a couple of years. Our next manager has to be the right choice and a competent manager that can unite out fanbase. If any of you seriously think that this clown Silva, who is nothing more then a very poor man's Martinez is the answer then you need to head testing!

Kienic · January 21, 2018

LiamG said:
Chelsea are another club that change their managers regularly. It does them no harm.

Difference there is they win, even the next manager usually wins something within 2yrs, us, that's a different story, someone brought up Atletico, that would be similar in a way as they at that point were cack also and winning nothing when they were going through managers at a rapid rate.

COYBL25 · January 21, 2018

PhilM said:
To be fair to @4737carlin, I've always been been vocal how I'd even consider Rafael. It would be incredibly galling, but he's a very god manager.

He`d have to be an instant success for the fans to take to him

Marius57 · January 21, 2018

Gwladysstreetlad said:
For the love of god no! Why cant some of you see that Silva is yet another flavour of mouth manager who has achieved absolutely nothing of significance and would be another disastrous appointment for us. Half of you only want him because your so blinded by hatred for Allardyce that you cant see that its better to be stuck with BFS till the end of the season then with Silva for a couple of years. Our next manager has to be the right choice and a competent manager that can unite out fanbase. If any of you seriously think that this clown Silva, who is nothing more then a very poor man's Maerinez then you need to head testing!

No manager that has achieved anything of significance is going to come to us regardless. And the rate we are going, we aren’t going to get to 40 points with sam. Struggling to get shots at home to West Brom says it all. Sam looks beaten already.

Gwladysstreetlad · January 21, 2018

Marius57 said:
No manager that has achieved anything of significance is going to come to us regardless. And the rate we are going, we aren’t going to get to 40 points with sam. Struggling to get shots at home to West Brom says it all. Sam looks beaten already.

And you think that Silva is the man to lead us to safety then? Based on what? Being relgated with Hull or his recent form with Watford? Not wanting Big Sam isn't a good enough reason to want Silva here.

ToffeeTim · January 21, 2018

Gracia would have been a good appointment for us. Did well with an utterly woeful malaga squad.

PhilM · January 21, 2018

COYBL25 said:
He`d have to be an instant success for the fans to take to him

True and I do think some fans would never take for him and perhaps rightly so because of some of his comments; his ties to them I could accept.

He is however probably a much better manager than most of the other people we could realistically aim for. Still, it won't ever happen!

LiamG · January 21, 2018

Toffeelover said:
They can afford it.

So can we. We just need to stop giving managers 5 year contracts.

5 year contracts for managers are crazy in this environment. Unless clubs start buying and selling managers for 100m it makes no sense.

EnglishRoundabout · January 21, 2018

Gwladysstreetlad said:
For the love of god no! Why cant some of you see that Silva is yet another flavour of mouth manager who has achieved absolutely nothing of significance and would be another disastrous appointment for us. Half of you only want him because your so blinded by hatred for Allardyce that you cant see that its better to be stuck with BFS till the end of the season then with Silva for a couple of years. Our next manager has to be the right choice and a competent manager that can unite out fanbase. If any of you seriously think that this clown Silva, who is nothing more then a very poor man's Martinez is the answer then you need to head testing!

Can I ask, where do you keep your crystal ball?

LiamG · January 21, 2018

Gwladysstreetlad said:
For the love of god no! Why cant some of you see that Silva is yet another flavour of mouth manager who has achieved absolutely nothing of significance and would be another disastrous appointment for us. Half of you only want him because your so blinded by hatred for Allardyce that you cant see that its better to be stuck with BFS till the end of the season then with Silva for a couple of years. Our next manager has to be the right choice and a competent manager that can unite out fanbase. If any of you seriously think that this clown Silva, who is nothing more then a very poor man's Martinez is the answer then you need to head testing!

Again who would you want?