Good post mate. Some of the criticism is OTT.
But we've also got to recognise we've not won a game since 16th December. The longest winless streak in the league and the longest we've gone without a win since 1994. Sure, there's mitigation there and we've drawn a few - but our form since our last win is joint worse in the league and relegation form.
Any Everton manager who is on the longest run in the league without a win, with relegation form over the last 10 weeks and scoring the first goal from open play in 10 league games should have some questions.
Without that point deduction I'm saying "brilliant, a season without blood pressure problems" but I'd still be asking questions.
My sentiment exactly. I'm not saying sack him tonight, but it's a bit rich to me that so many people are hammering Dom for not scoring in forever but are willing to let Dyche off the hook with stats like the bold above.
If anything, I'm willing to cut Dom more slack, because a forward can't pass the ball to himself. But a manager is in charge of his own tactics, substitutions, etc. etc. Nobody but himself has those responsibilities.
So for me, the run of 9 or 10 games we had months ago where we picked up a lot of points against a mostly favorable schedule isn't enough to preclude all criticism now. We can recognize some achievements for the season as a whole and also notice that the trends feel decidedly downward lately. Does anyone think the team is currently improving in almost any way? What are we really better at now than we were say 4 months ago?
Shouldn't a manager have to answer for that at some level?