Probably in the minority of people who thought Barkley rightly deserves his place in the team. He has the best attacking stats of any other England midfielder this season despite the team's performance. He is a very frustrating player granted but for me there's no doubt in my mind he deserves to be there. His consistency and maturation is overlooked when people knee jerk every time he loses the ball or hesitates to pass.
Depends what Hodgson is picking on. If it's form then Barkley is in the squad but perhaps not the starting line up. Henderson Wilshere and Sterling would be nowhere near it though. If it's who contributed to qualifying then Barkley should be in the team as should Carrick, Baines, Jags.
We all know though that any England managers selection is always based on 'what will the media like?'. So therefore we are carrying two central midfielders who have barely played for their clubs, a pair of left backs who hardly featured in qualifying, 2/3 of our first choice midfield have two international caps, and a striker who has not yet played even half a season of league football. Yet some people seriously think we might win it.
Heads should roll at the FA for our embarassing approach to tournament football. Other countries plan for a two year qualifying campaign. They pick similar squads over the course of that and then make minor changes either for new players in great form or injuries. Our squad barely resembles the one that started. We've not even settled on a preferred formation. Kane and Vardy have had a few games together, Rooney had just decided he's now a midfielder, Wilshere Henderson Dier Alli have barely played together for England, we don't know what the first choice CB pairing is (seeing as Jags took us through qualifying) and we have no idea who will start at full backs.
Same old same old every single year.