Pound for Pound - last 30 years

Charlie Sweet · June 17, 2015

Last 30 years which Everyon players have put in the most consistent high quality performances?

So for all those players that'd played say at least 25 matches - who would have the highest average ratings from the watching fans/journalists. For me its:

1. Lineker
2. Bracewell
3. Rooney
4. Sheedy
5. Beardsley
6. Kanchelskis
7. Stones
8. Southall
9. Stevens
10. Cahill

Its not easy....

TrixyStevens · June 17, 2015

It is easy IMO.
Southall.

Prevenger17 · June 17, 2015

dholliday · June 17, 2015

Charlie Sweet said:
Last 30 years which Everyon players have put in the most consistent high quality performances?

So for all those players that'd played say at least 25 matches - who would have the highest average ratings from the watching fans/journalists. For me its:

1. Lineker
2. Bracewell
3. Rooney
4. Sheedy
5. Beardsley
6. Kanchelskis
7. Stones
8. Southall
9. Stevens
10. Cahill

Its not easy....

Lineker yeah, tho' Big Nev easily number two then. Beardsley & Sheedy up there.

Rooney was off the pace in a lot of games for us in his second season...he's not top 10. Tony Cottee is.

Gwladysstreetlad · June 17, 2015

TrixyStevens said:
It is easy IMO.
Southall.

This 100%.

The Equaliser · June 17, 2015

Jaysus Charlie that's a tough one at 1am in the morning like.

I'll have to have a think about it and revert.

dholliday · June 17, 2015

Ratcliffe up there too

Charlie Sweet · June 17, 2015

TrixyStevens said:
It is easy IMO.
Southall.

All about opinions

For at least half his time at Goodison be was truly world class and best in the league but I maybe think his last couple of years would have knocked it a bit.

The Equaliser · June 17, 2015

Right, I've thought about it and the correct answer is Kanchelskis.

tim gabbott · June 17, 2015

Howard or hibert

blue4eva77 · June 17, 2015

Southall

summerisle · June 17, 2015

Peter Reid deserves as least to get in the top ten. Alan Harper is almost the forgotten man :

degreeinblue · June 17, 2015

Lacuna Traore, im not buying this 25 game rule.

The Equaliser · June 17, 2015

For those nominating Big Nev, the question asked "which Everyon players have put in the most consistent high quality performances?"

Although he was the greatest Everton keeper in history, his performance levels dipped in the early nineties until he was revitalised in 1994 when Joe Royle became manager.

blue4eva77 · June 17, 2015

The Equaliser said:
For those nominating Big Nev, the question asked "which Everyon players have put in the most consistent high quality performances?"

Although he was the greatest Everton keeper in history, his performance levels dipped in the early nineties until he was revitalised in 1994 when Joe Royle became manager.

He was also equally magnificent for at least a decade and extremely consistent.