Pienaar over-rated?

[RFUS]

As an individual he is maybe overrated, but for us his contribution to the team isn't.


There's a reason he's only ever truly shone with us; we're a perfect match. Him and Baines have probably the best partnership I've ever seen between two Everton players.


I'm fairly certain when he leaves, he'll regret it within a year, from a footballing perspective. I'm sure the extra dosh will ease the pain, like.

 

[DionDublin]

in the past decade, Pienaar is comfortably our best left sided midfielder (despite being a centre mid)

real shame to lose him.

 

[chicoazul]

He's one of our best players by some distance.

 

[Nordecke]

No, he is a fantastic little player and will be sorely missed. Stevie has technical ability most of the MF don't have, he is quick and nimble and can turn a game on it's head, i can't think of any other players like him.

Mikky - hit and miss for about 12 months
Felli - a purple patch before his injury, extremely promising.
Osman - workman like, little end result, not enough goals.
Rodwell, commanding and powerful - again, not enough goals.
Bily - < ...... >
Stevie, skillful, provides assists, scores a couple, quick and always up for it.

1 assist, 1 goal.. Boy's on fire.

 

[little curly alan ball]

He's one of our best players by some distance.

HE'S ALSO SO-O-O-O-O-O GONE , according to the one with S on his chest , earlier today...

 

[little curly alan ball]

Over rated - No. Should we cash in on him in the transfer window? It would make sense to get a decent sum of money for a player who cost peanuts. As long as Moyes got the money to spend on a proven replacement.

Best result would be for him to sign the dotted line and put us out of our misery.

There will BE NO CASHING IN .

He's uny got 5 months left .

We'll get 30 bob an' Keane or Krancjar .

 

[EFCTim Cahill]

wasn't dejected about losing him until, Donovan announced he wasn't coming back, now I am

 

[RFUS]

There will BE NO CASHING IN .

He's uny got 5 months left .

We'll get 30 bob an' Keane or Krancjar .

On a loan, surely? No one's going to straight swap players for someone who'll be free in 6 months.


Really hope it's Niko.

 

[chicoazul]

HE'S ALSO SO-O-O-O-O-O GONE , according to the one with S on his chest , earlier today...

I always said he was [Poor language removed] mate, get rid etc.

 

[ToffeeMark]

If he goes he is overated, if he stays he is ok.

Osman is better, lovely to see him back against city

 

[Fazakerley_Blue]

There will BE NO CASHING IN .

He's uny got 5 months left .

We'll get 30 bob an' Keane or Krancjar .

Free in the summer or some cash in January, ie. if we sell in Jan we will be cashing in, if only a fraction of what he's worth.