Philip John Neville

Status
Not open for further replies.

Its been great to see how he has supported Coleman in his new role, if you look at the game Neville is generally never more then 20 yards away from Seamus, very underatted by us, offers us something different slotting back into the midfeild as well.
 
Great Captain, top player.

Is it just coincidence that we've gone on a good run since he's been back??

And how many times has THAT been said? He's a crucial part of the team, irreplaceable even.

When Arteta's out, Pienaar steps up. When Pienaar's out, Arteta steps up. When both of them are out then Baines and Cahill can step up. When the strikers are out Cahill steps up. We have lots of key players who make us better by them being in the team, but I don't think any other single player has the same massive influence that Neville has. He'll be some manager in a few years.
 

I've always said he's a great captain, but an average player.

However, recently I've realised how much there is to his game, from a mental perspective. He's very average technically -- poor even -- but just look how he neutralised Bale -- something even Maicon and Lucio couldn't seem to do. He's a wily old campaigner, and a top notch captain.
 
I've always said he's a great captain, but an average player.

However, recently I've realised how much there is to his game, from a mental perspective. He's very average technically -- poor even -- but just look how he neutralised Bale -- something even Maicon and Lucio couldn't seem to do. He's a wily old campaigner, and a top notch captain.


spot on. pretty solid defensively. always above average to great. doesnt really ever have a howler of a game like distin against manu

he is our team. he is our leader.
weird, cause i never really rated him. thought he was old and average. but as of late ive changed my mind
 
come on lads.

time for a bit of realism

he is average at best, possibly poor.

He is getting on and offers us nothing in terms of ability but plenty in terms of 'other attributes'.

As moyes admit himself 'he might not be the best player' , no david he is not, he is one of our worst.

Im sorry, I have ago at the kopites (and rightly so) that Kuyt gets in their team for his work rate over ability. Phil Neville gets in our team for leadership over ability.

And do I need to mention the rubbish he comes out with in the press?
 
I've always said he's a great captain, but an average player.

However, recently I've realised how much there is to his game, from a mental perspective. He's very average technically -- poor even -- but just look how he neutralised Bale -- something even Maicon and Lucio couldn't seem to do. He's a wily old campaigner, and a top notch captain.

Disgree. Although Bale took his goals well, for me it was simply inter dropping the pace in the last 5 minutes. He never took on maicon or lucio it was zanetti who he destroyed watch the goals back!! Bale is good bt by god inter (zanetti) made it easy.
 

come on lads.

time for a bit of realism

he is average at best, possibly poor.

He is getting on and offers us nothing in terms of ability but plenty in terms of 'other attributes'.

As moyes admit himself 'he might not be the best player' , no david he is not, he is one of our worst.

Im sorry, I have ago at the kopites (and rightly so) that Kuyt gets in their team for his work rate over ability. Phil Neville gets in our team for leadership over ability.

And do I need to mention the rubbish he comes out with in the press?

The only important piece of your post im afraid dion.
 
come on lads.

time for a bit of realism

he is average at best, possibly poor.

He is getting on and offers us nothing in terms of ability but plenty in terms of 'other attributes'.

As moyes admit himself 'he might not be the best player' , no david he is not, he is one of our worst.

Im sorry, I have ago at the kopites (and rightly so) that Kuyt gets in their team for his work rate over ability. Phil Neville gets in our team for leadership over ability.

And do I need to mention the rubbish he comes out with in the press?

I'm sorry but Neville is our best RB at the club at the moment. Certainly the most complete RB we have as he's solid defensively and he can join in the attack. He's first choice without a doubt for me and his fantastic leadership skills also bring an important attribute to the team.
 
Disgree. Although Bale took his goals well, for me it was simply inter dropping the pace in the last 5 minutes. He never took on maicon or lucio it was zanetti who he destroyed watch the goals back!! Bale is good bt by god inter (zanetti) made it easy.

Well you're being a pedant.

My point was less about Maicon, and more about Neville and Bale. Bale is very good, so you can't be that bad if you keep him quiet.
 
He's a poor player by our standards. And I say by our standards because we have a host of excellent footballing players. However, as cringeworthy as it is, his experience, leadership or whatever you want to call it, is still important.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top