Osman v Bilyaletdinov

Greek Fisherman · October 28, 2011

I don't get why Bily gets crucified week in week out, yet Osman seems to get off scot free despite playing like absolute sh!te!!

I just watched the Chelsea game and if Moyes offered the same support to Bily that he does Osman it would be be chalk and cheese.

Play him on the right or central and leave him there.

BLUES1 · October 28, 2011

I don't think either should start. Drenthe on one side Coleman on the other.

McBain · October 28, 2011

Ossie is a championship player 90% of the time.

Summerskin · October 28, 2011

They're both mint and I should be Everton coach so we could all revel in their mint-ness.

Blue 1 · October 28, 2011

'Cos Ossie is local, didn't cost £9m so doesn't come with the expectation to perform that Billy does, has had far more good games than Billy and was our best player for the latter part of last season so his credit is probably still good with lots of people?

SteveSC · October 28, 2011

Greek Fisherman said:
I don't get why Bily gets crucified week in week out, yet Osman seems to get off scot free despite playing like absolute sh!te!!

It wasn't long ago when osman and hibbert were getting the same treatment by the fans maybe bily is the new osman.

Dom1878 · October 28, 2011

Speaking about bily, the chelsea match was ridiculous, he was the best player on the pitch, and not only did he get subbed (let's hope that doesn't affect his confidence) but the slightest mistake and every fan moaned! Where as you had drenthe who lost the ball more times than anyone but got praised. Bily was great the other day and the fans and moyes need to give him a chance - and by that I mean a run of games where he is comfortable playing.

As for osman everyone was bumming him last season, he has a high work rate, and is good for the squad, but there are so many quality players who don't get a chance because of him, and we shouldn't sacrifice our better players so we can have someone to run around

Chang Elephant · October 28, 2011

Dom1878 said:
As for osman everyone was bumming him last season, he has a high work rate, and is good for the squad, but there are so many quality players who don't get a chance because of him, and we shouldn't sacrifice our better players so we can have someone to run around

I have a higher work rate than him.

Bily is a footballer.

ijjysmith · October 28, 2011

Bily should start.

Alio · October 28, 2011

Bilyaletdinov has a price tag, that's why he'll get more stick. Saying that, both get equal amounts of bashing from what I see

Haven't seen much of Wednesday's game, but sounds like Bily did well. Would like to see him get a start on Saturday

I fancy him to Beat De Gea with a long ranger. I think it's science or something that he'll score this weekend with a beauty

Deano · October 28, 2011

If he's going to play Bily he should drop Cahill and play him behind the striker. But we all know Moyes isn't willing to drop his favorite bumtoys.

MoreCows · October 28, 2011

Play both.

Summerskin · October 28, 2011

Only seen the highlights but made up some are saying Billy was one of the better ones out there, come on Dini!

BigBlueConk · October 28, 2011

Both are doomed never to play in their best position.

Zatara · October 28, 2011

Osman and Hibbert were finished in my eyes after the FA cup final.

Cahill and Neville shouldnt be here this season....

Anichebe should be sold.....

Bilyaletdinov should be in the hole....Coleman right back with drenthe in front of him.....