Mike Walker V Roberto Martinez

[mixed_up]

Roberto Martinez does not deserve to be compared to Mike Walker

 

[ianefc]

People are going to misread the title and vote for who they think is the best instead, hence me voting Mike Walker and not being able to change it.

It's too close to call, I wouldn't worry you were inadvertently right anyway.

 

[ianefc]

Roberto Martinez does not deserve to be compared to Mike Walker

You're mixed up

 

[ilikecheese]

You like having your hopes built up? Only to be dashed in emphatic style.

When we tonked Arsenal 3-0 and then moved into 4th the next week was the best I've felt about Everton in a very long time.

So yeah...daring to dream and building hope is all part of it.

 

[chrismpw]

Walker was worse. I don't remember a single highlight or moment of pleasure with Walker. Martinez gave us two. A cracking first season and euro fun, and when he left.

 

[MikeH72]

Roberto Martinez does not deserve to be compared to Mike Walker

I know, someone who finished SECOND with NORWICH CITY being compared to the Prem's worst ever manager. Shocking.

 

[nsno-chris]

Walker was worse. I don't remember a single highlight or moment of pleasure with Walker. Martinez gave us two. A cracking first season and euro fun, and when he left.

6-2 against Swindon, what a time to be alive

 

[Connor]

72 POINTS.

 

[Saint Domingo]

Does Mike Walker have the worst home record in Everton's entire history? Don't think he does.

 

[mixed_up]

I know, someone who finished SECOND with NORWICH CITY being compared to the Prem's worst ever manager. Shocking.

that's with Norwich City not Everton though. Martinez won the fa cup with wigan but that's not my reasoning.

 

[ianefc]

When we tonked Arsenal 3-0 and then moved into 4th the next week was the best I've felt about Everton in a very long time.

So yeah...daring to dream and building hope is all part of it.

Did we move into 4th?

 

[mixed_up]

Mike Walker conceded 52 goals in his 31 games, left us bottom with one win out of 14 games before he was sacked.

 

[ilikecheese]

Did we move into 4th?

Yes.

 

[toffee matt]

Only one manger conceded 9 goals in 3 games at Anfield scoring 1.

Not forgetting losing a Semi Final whilst 3 - 1 up on aggregate and getting battered at Wembley by the worst United side in years.

Walker wasn't even here a year either Martinez had 3

 

[Harryflashman]

I actually voted originally without reading it correctly because it seemed such an easy choice . So I've actually voted incorrectly !

Martinez doesn't deserve to be compared to walker , not even close in my opinion . Walker was a joke and his time was woeful , I honestly think Martinez had some bad luck . A few times it looked like we were so close but things didn't work out and the end just had to come as it'd gone completely wrong and change was desperately needed . I'd have loved it to work but sadly it didn't .