Transfer Rumour Memphis Depay

Would Memphis be a good signing for Everton?

  • Yes

    Votes: 508 63.9%

  • No

    Votes: 206 25.9%

  • Scouse Pay on Toast

    Votes: 81 10.2%
  • Total voters
    795
Status
Not open for further replies.
Zatara said:
You keep harping on about that even though youve been presented with all the evidence (publicly available on the internet) showing he would have relegated them if he wasnt sacked and nobody at the club cared about the cup as they wrre in such a mess thanks to him.
Click to expand...

Have I just been transported back in time to about a month ago?

Let it go Zat.
 

Zatara said:
You keep harping on about that even though youve been presented with all the evidence (publicly available on the internet) showing he would have relegated them if he wasnt sacked and nobody at the club cared about the cup as they wrre in such a mess thanks to him.
Click to expand...

I showed you video evidence of 000s of fans celebrating their cup win.

I also highlighted the fact that when he was sacked they were 5 points above relegation and they infact finished the season 10th.

But nevermind Zat, you keep holding that 9 year grudge, honest question here, did you support Valencia in 2007?
 
Connor said:
I've seen plenty of Depay - Eredivise games and over here - to make a judgement on him. Don't assume anything.
Click to expand...

Anyone, literally anyone whose seen Depay in Holland or at United before he made those defensive errors can see he has all the ability in the world.

He single handedly tore Fenerbahce apart and wasnt bad against brugge last season either.

Theres a star there.
 

Regards Depay.

Hes been utter pony so far in England, but there has been signs of a very good player there.

I have no concerns regarding his talent, but his attitude stinks and I have slight concerns regarding Ronnys man management, Depay needs telling hes the best player in the room and thats not Ronnys style.

Still, I personally think it would work out if we signed him, but I dont think we will.
 
Zatara said:
Anyone, literally anyone whose seen Depay in Holland or at United before he made those defensive errors can see he has all the ability in the world.

He single handedly tore Fenerbahce apart and wasnt bad against brugge last season either.

Theres a star there.
Click to expand...

But buying from Holland should always come with a Buyer Beware tag, it can go either way.

He's flopped at United, plain and simple.

He can do fantastic things with the ball but he's struggles in many aspects of the English game. He is a YouTube player who will shine in 2/3 games a season over here and probably needs to move away.

If he comes here in January and looks like his PSV self, I'll hold my hands up and admit defeat but I'm not sold on him playing over here for much longer.
 
Zatara said:
I made a post in error, whereas you and @Dymak keep on slating a player neither of you have seen play.

Just the same nonsense was spoted about VVD on here when @Mikey_Fitzgerald and I were saying how good he was and now he's rated as one of the best centre backs around.

I think its becoming quite comical reading...

Keep it up.
Click to expand...

To be fair, Dymak hates everyone
 

Zatara said:
Fixed.
Click to expand...

Mate you are always on about give youth a chance, give this a chance etc. But you refuse to give Bolasie a chance after a dozen games, given also that he has been the only creative presence in the team.

In order for others to take on board your comments, surely you need to give the likes of Bolaise a chance, and to a lesser extent Koeman, as you have made it clear your feelings towards him


Thoughts?
 
Young players can improve, Bolasie and Koeman have track records at previous clubs and are both shocking.

Depays track record is top notch but clearly made the wrong move.
 
Zatara said:
Young players can improve, Bolasie and Koeman have track records at previous clubs and are both shocking.

Depays track record is top notch but clearly made the wrong move.
Click to expand...
His track record in leagues where Altidore hasn't scored 30 goals is shocking too. I'd love to sign him but he could be worse than the crap we have out there already
 
MoutsGoat said:
Juan Mata, a player given his debut by Ronald Koeman.
Click to expand...
I am not joining in and picking a side, here, but I think he was referencing the United supporters who were all too happy to get shut of Mata over the break, and now he is rejuvenated under Mourinho.

Therefore, United fans know shazbat about footy, therefore shouldn't be relied on as an authority as to whether Depay is any good or not.

I want him to join solely because his name is 'Memphis'.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top