Martin Atkinson gets no punishment!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Everton_ev

Player Valuation: £225k
Just been released that Atkinson will be reffing Stoke vs Fulham next week. Disgrace tbh

Referee-Martin-Atkinson-007.jpg


http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2011/oct/10/merseyside-derby-referee-martin-atkinson

The referee Martin Atkinson has escaped a temporary demotion from the Premier League for this weekend's fixtures despite a three-man Football Association appeals panel overturning his decision to send off Everton's Jack Rodwell in the Merseyside derby.

Rodwell's appeal for wrongful dismissal against his controversial red card, awarded for a 23rd-minute challenge on Luis Suárez, was upheld last week, prompting the midfielder's three-match ban to be withdrawn and allowing him to play against Chelsea in the Premier League and Carling Cup, and Fulham in the league.

Everton went on to lose the game 2-0 and the Premier League and Professional Game Match Officials Limited were expected to consider the error which seriously affected the home side's chances against Liverpool when they addressed this weekend's appointments.

However, the governing bodies have since decided not to force Atkinson to drop down the divisions this weekend, with the official to take charge of the game between Stoke City and Fulham on Saturday. Atkinson is one of the more highly regarded referees within PGMOL, and the referee assessors are content that the error at Goodison Park was an exception and not one of a series of mistakes.

The Everton chief executive, Robert Elstone, had welcomed the decision to rescind the red card, but had suggested the club's earnings through their league finish might end up being affected regardless.

"While we obviously welcome the news, it is no consolation to nearly 40,000 fans who had gone to the game expecting to see a contest," said Elstone at the time. "We don't know if the decision cost us one or three points, but at nearly £1m a place in prize money in the Premier League these days, it could prove to be a really expensive mistake, not to mention the biggest disappointment for Jack."
 

A complete joke. He'll be "Clattenburg'd" - as in put on the list of referees not allowed to official our matches.

But to be honest, the way things are going that'd mean there will be none left. They're nearly all useless.

Technology ASAP. Rugby is the model to use.
 
A complete joke. He'll be "Clattenburg'd" - as in put on the list of referees not allowed to official our matches.

But to be honest, the way things are going that'd mean there will be none left. They're nearly all useless.

Technology ASAP. Rugby is the model to use.
Only for goal line for me no matter how bad some refs are or get,it would just be to stop/start for me,even though you will say it will take seconds,i can see some taking minutes to decide on some things
 
Only for goal line for me no matter how bad some refs are or get,it would just be to stop/start for me,even though you will say it will take seconds,i can see some taking minutes to decide on some things

it wont take longer than the time-wasters or injury fakers etc
 
A complete joke. He'll be "Clattenburg'd" - as in put on the list of referees not allowed to official our matches.

But to be honest, the way things are going that'd mean there will be none left. They're nearly all useless.

Technology ASAP. Rugby is the model to use.

100% agree. If you watch ten games of superleague you'll get nearly spot on reffing. It doesn't wreck the flow of the game because they only go to the video game for decisions that aren't obvious anyway and would probably have slowed the game down regardless. Superleague have it spot on when it comes to reffing and officials.
 

I'm sorry but they should simply make it like tennis, no technology involved at all other than 3 challanges per team per match (if necessary). I.e, we challange the refs decision on rodwells red, and video is used to review the decision quickly and get on with the game.
 

I can't look at that photo without wanting to punch him.

I would smack him if I saw him. Respect campaign my left testicle
 
If he made the same mistake against the sh*te then you can bet your left teste that he would be demoted for a decade.
Or shot more likely.

I'm sorry but they should simply make it like tennis, no technology involved at all other than 3 challanges per team per match (if necessary). I.e, we challange the refs decision on rodwells red, and video is used to review the decision quickly and get on with the game.

Got to say I don't like that idea. 3 challenges made and then the other team can be as snidey as they like, knowing the videos can't be called on.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top