2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

[Frang]

Eddie Howe anyone?

his premier league stats aren't that much better than silva's .. alltho howes is over a much much longer period, not 3 half seasons at 3 different clubs like silva..

and obviosly the difference in club size should not be over looked. Bournemouth are an absolte minnow with zero money so his achievments stand up to be credible at the very least

 

[billyblue80]

Chopping and changing managers is part of the reason we were a mess last season and still have big issues. Our squad is still a mish-mash. Sacking Silva and getting another Big Sam type will be a sticking plaster and will only continue our downward spiral in the long term. Am I sure Silva is taking us anywhere? No, but he is at least trying to implement a style he needs at least this season to get the team he wants. He can be naive but I've seen flashes of a new Everton. I hope this is partly a result of the big blow to our confidence that losing at the RS dealt us. And we can turn it around.

 

[dannyboy]

I'm sure his nose is getting bigger by the week. Anyway, it's the ref and players' fault.

We started the game well? No we didn't. We should have been two down by the time we scored.

 

[Frang]

I'm sure his nose is getting bigger by the week. Anyway, it's the ref and players' fault.

how can we lose organisation that wasn't there in the first place... hes already buckling under the pressure

 

[Milk]

his premier league stats aren't that much better than silva's .. alltho howes is over a much much longer period, not 3 half seasons at 3 different clubs like silva..

and obviosly the difference in club size should not be over looked. Bournemouth are an absolte minnow with zero money so his achievments stand up to be credible at the very least

And his teams play as a team
Attractive stuff too considering they don’t have the supposed quality we are alleged to have

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

united is united … its a one off, and for most a poison chalice.

even being a failure at united is wiining the Europa league, fa cup and coming 2nd in a very strong league.

hes even got them through to the last 16 of champs league …

so obviously we would rather stick with a premier league fraud and pass up on this serial winner.

there are levels in football... Mourinho would be at about 95 -100 right now and we have magical marco who is about 2 -100

*face-palms

But that ignores how they were the biggest spenders during his time there. It is quite a poor return.

And his tactical genius seemed to be just resorting to the long ball to Fellaini when chasing a game.

The problem at United is they let their squad get old and also the owners were using it as a piggy bank. They’ve been throwing money at it (sound familiar)but the structural weaknesses were not addressed.

 

[Frang]

Chopping and changing managers is part of the reason we were a mess last season and still have big issues. Sacking Silva and getting another Big Sak type will only continue our downward spiral. Am I sure Silva is taking us anywhere? No but he is at least trying to implement a style he needs at least this season to get the team he wants.

we are getting exactly what was hired tho… mediocre manager who cant halt a slump in form.

if silva had finished a whole season and got Watford to a 5th/6th place finish, then he would have some standing.

as it is, he got sacked for putting in performances like today

are we just expecting him to suddenly start thinking in a whole different way and get us defending properly??? the fella is a one trick pony

 

[Eagle Eye]

No mate go look at the results after week one against Stoke, we didn’t get a win apart from the miracle Niasse comeback

We also were in the relegation zone and bombed out of Europe

An if the season started 9 games ago, we would be in the relegation zone now. Scrappy one nil win at home to Cardiff and a 3-1 win at home to Brighton. There's your Stoke and Bournemouth equivalents right there. It really is no different.

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

It's not the United standard though, that's why he was booted, if they finished 4-5 points then it'd be ok but 19?

We don't deserve nice things period because we have sections of the fan base who feel the need to be proven right and score points instead of thinking logically and with more common sense. Everyone took to Martinez too quickly and it blew up in everyone's face, no one really took to Koeman and no one demanded Allardyce but we cannot just keep turning on managers or things will never ever settled down at this club

They were quite happy with last season, but they had their worse start in 30 years or something after spending more than everyone else.

Ed Woodward and Moshiri would make one hell of an executive”dream team!”

 

[Frang]

And his teams play as a team
Attractive stuff too considering they don’t have the supposed quality we are alleged to have

his whole mantra is built around team ethic

he did a radio interview where he talked about how he goes about things and what has made him successful, he came across very well

 

[ijjysmith]

But that ignores how they were the biggest spenders during his time there. It is quite a poor return.

And his tactical genius seemed to be just resorting to the long ball to Fellaini when chasing a game.

The problem at United is they let their squad get old and also the owners were using it as a piggy bank. They’ve been throwing money at it (sound familiar)but the structural weaknesses were not addressed.

Wish we had Fellaini to lob on.

 

[nsno-chris]

It was a gamble appointment

I like his ideas

I don’t like what I’ve witnessed in the last 6 weeks

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

Wish we had Fellaini to lob on.

Yeah, love the big guy. United fans hate him, even though he won them the Europa.

 

[EverBlue92]

It's not the United standard though, that's why he was booted, if they finished 4-5 points then it'd be ok but 19?

We don't deserve nice things period because we have sections of the fan base who feel the need to be proven right and score points instead of thinking logically and with more common sense. Everyone took to Martinez too quickly and it blew up in everyone's face, no one really took to Koeman and no one demanded Allardyce but we cannot just keep turning on managers or things will never ever settled down at this club

I agree we definitely need stability mate... however that stability has to be stability of progression and competitiveness.

No point settling for stability if its regression as that soon becomes unstable as we saw in Martinez's 3rd season.

Our problem is Moshiri has appointed flavour of the month mid table managers and has failed to undertake a proper recruitment policy.

Brands should have been tasked with scouring Europe for a new manager not tapping up a bloke who had a decent few games at Watford.

The ownership and recruitment policy is preventing any kind of stability at present.

 

[Frang]

But that ignores how they were the biggest spenders during his time there. It is quite a poor return.

And his tactical genius seemed to be just resorting to the long ball to Fellaini when chasing a game.

The problem at United is they let their squad get old and also the owners were using it as a piggy bank. They’ve been throwing money at it (sound familiar)but the structural weaknesses were not addressed.

he would walk straight in and instil a winning mentality.
everyone would have to listen to him, and I mean everyone.

this is how you do this, and that is how you do that, no more of this and no more of that, what the hell have you been running here

all while bill creams his kecks in the corner