2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

Grade Marco Silva's 2018/19 Season

  • A

  • B

  • C

  • D

  • E

  • F

Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unless we look likely to get relegated, I think he should be given this whole season to form his team and style. If its the same struggles next season, then we have to start over with a better manager. I wasnt hyped on Silva myself, but there are signs of good football afoot, and I do t want us to change managers every season.
 
Last edited:
Nyhus said:
Unless we look likely to get relegated, I think he should be given this whole season to form his team and style. If its the same struggles next season, then we have to start over with a better manager. I wasnt hyped on Silva myself, but there are signs of good football afoot, and I do t want us to change managers every season.
Click to expand...
I do believe that is exactly what will happen. I think he is probably being assessed at present more by how is managing the club and the players rather than results alone.
I think that only a disastrous situation would see him lose his job.
 
Blue Roo said:
This type of reasoning from a manger is just a cop out.
Koeman tried to transplant a system on top of what he had and it was a shambles.
And its appearing at the moment that the powers that be haven't learnt their lesson.
If you don't think you have the players to do a good job at CF, take the glass half full mindset and adapt.
Keep the core principles but find another way to get where you want to go with what's in front of you.

Given the path Silva is trying to get to the CF isn't really the issue atm.
There are more fundamental things to address irrespective of whether he's got a CF like Lukaku or not.
I'd rather see us have more than 6 points because he's getting other things right rather than DCL tapping that goal in.
You've got to ask yourself the question - would we have won the game if DCL had scored that goal?
As it was, we had that game lost at 0-0 when the teams headed for the tunnel at half time.
Emry was in control of the game from that point on.

Silva had the players to win that match.
Click to expand...

Adapt the core principles? We're 6 games in, the players haven't even gotten used to the core principles yet let alone be able to play a way the manager isn't used to training players (and I'll say it again) 6 games in!

Ask yourself this before you ask anything. Would we of won at wolves if jags hadn't of been sent off? Would we of beaten Bournemouth if we'd of gotten two penalties we should of gotten? Would we of beaten Huddersfield and west ham if richarlison had of played? Or if that lad who super kicked Walcott in the head for west ham had been sent off or we got the penalty on sigurdsson in that match. Or if that arsenal lad had of been sent off for his second challenge one dinge?

There has been alit that has went against us this season but apart from the west ham match we have looked the better side in every other game. In my opinion if richarlison doesn't get sent off at Bournemouth or Bernard is fit we're looking at a extra 7 points on the board.

Emery was in control? By doing what? Switching aubameyang to a striker, what a brain wave its not like hes world class striker or anything. Was that why we bossed them from the start of the second half to the first goal? Arsenal hit us with two goals in 3 minutes and the lads heads went down and arsenals went up. Its unfortunate but we did have our youngest squad out since 1998. Arsenal had 110m worth of top class strikers in their prime and our entire front 3 cost less then half of that and 2 of them are 21.

People need to realise that this is a project and will take time. We need to sort out the squad to be suited to play silvas way. Atm we still have players from moyes, martinez, koeman and allerdyce. All different manager with completely different styles of play bringing in players for that style. A lot of them won't be suited to silvas style at first and some of them never will and will need replacing but this will take time to see who fits and who needs replacing.

Fortunately the next two position that need filling seem to be the obvious ones. The striker and midfield area but can that be sorted out in January or will it have to be a wait till the summer job?

For me I'm happy with Silva so far and he has my complete backing because I am seeing improvements in every game and we are playing the most atracking football i have seen for a long time at goodison. we still have players to come in. Its my hope that Silva will throw everything into the leauge cup this season. Its a cup none of the top sides are that bothered about and I think we can win especially with two of the top 6 sides already out and the rest being I more interested in Europe.
 
you underestimate appeal of premier league and big club like Everton..throwing money at next bale,modric and van der vaart and not tosun and sigurdsson is between here and next level
 
When you spend more on a goalie and a centre half than your main striker then ambition should be questioned, however Liverpool have signed Suarez, Salah, Mane, Firminho, Sturridge for not much more than we’ve spent on players and everyone of them would walk into our team. None of them were top top name strikers out of our reach, but it shows we either lack in scouting or stature.

Also if Mourinho can’t get it right at Utd with 400m he would never succeed here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

→ Log in 🔑 Register
🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top