2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

[BiggyRat]

That I agree 100%.
What I meant with Martinez was Bill giving him full control of the club like Moyes had. He didn't have the experience.
If he'd come in under someone like Brands then I believe he'd still be here now with a trophy under his belt.

When did that happen for Moyes though? How long had he been at the club before he got that power/authority? (Genuine Q)

 

[bicycleheader]

That’s just a waste of another season. We know, not just from his time here, but his time at Watford and Hull, that Silva cannot turn around a bad run of form. His weak tactics get found out.

It’s time for him to go. There is no case to be made for him to remain.

What's the plan after Silva?

 

[blulouie]

Completely different time.

I wouldn’t have Moyes back, but finishing on 39 points with what he inherited from Walter Smith and the lack of budget he was working with was not completely unexpected.

Finishing on 39 points with this Everton team is ridiculous.

It wont be 39.

 

[GwladysBlue]

What's the plan after Silva?

Employ a better manager

 

[bicycleheader]

Employ a better manager

And how long do they get from you if they are in 11th this time next season? There's very few guarantees of success out there if we want somebody to actual move us forward, rather than just somebody to consolidate 8th and do not much more.

 

[GwladysBlue]

And how long do they get from you if they are in 11th this time next season? There's very few guarantees of success out there if we want somebody to actual move us forward, rather than just somebody to consolidate 8th and do not much more.

If they’re 11th this time next season, then the board have hired another bad manager.

 

[COYBL25]

What's the plan after Silva?

Keep shouting " sack the manager " every season ?

 

[bicycleheader]

If they’re 11th this time next season, then the board have hired another bad manager.

So sack again...even perhaps during the season?

 

[willo30]

When did that happen for Moyes though? How long had he been at the club before he got that power/authority? (Genuine Q)

Think it was all the time. We weren't an attractive proposition at the time and it was also Bill again that gave him it. We weren't really in any position to argue terms.
Football was big but nowhere as big as now so we got away with it.
When Bobby came in we were in a totally different position were any new manager would accept our terms. Bill acted like we were still small time and gave him what he wanted.

Only my opinion by the way.

 

[ijjysmith]

So sack again...even perhaps during the season?

But why stick with a quite clearly poor one mate?

 

[GwladysBlue]

So sack again...even perhaps during the season?

If the manager isn’t good enough? Certainly. Don’t see what you’re not understanding.

 

[bicycleheader]

But why stick with a quite clearly poor one mate?

I'm not saying we should, I'm wondering what the plan is from that particular poster Ijj

 

[BiggyRat]

Think it was all the time. We weren't an attractive proposition at the time and it was also Bill again that gave him it. We weren't really in any position to argue terms.
Football was big but nowhere as big as now so we got away with it.
When Bobby came in we were in a totally different position were any new manager would accept our terms. Bill acted like we were still small time and gave him what he wanted.

Only my opinion by the way.

Without living in the daily PL bubble, I tend to forget 'the details', but I could understand that power & trust for someone like SAF who turned that team into a juggernaut, but it's odd to get it for mid table consistency.

 

[ijjysmith]

I'm not saying we should, I'm wondering what the plan is from that particular poster Ijj

Luckily nobody on here needs to have any plans.

I’d if was me, I really would keep sacking them until we got the right one. But that’s just me.

I know that approach won’t be universally popular.

 

[willo30]

Without living in the daily PL bubble, I tend to forget 'the details', but I could understand that power & trust for someone like SAF who turned that team into a juggernaut, but it's odd to get it for mid table consistency.

Yes but we were relegation candidates when Moyes took over so didn't have a strong hand so to speak.
With Bobby though we were top 6 and he had just relegated Wigan. How Bill gave him free reign with them credentials still baffles me now.