Marcelo Bielsa or Sean Dyche?

Marcelo Bielsa or Sean Dyche?

  • Total voters
    526
Status
Not open for further replies.

I can't call this one taking into consideration our position.
If we where mid-table then Bielsa all day long.
Dyche is accustomed to relegation battles but still uncertain he can get us safe as his teams also lacked goals.
Bielsa could work something out attacking wise and could see us score more than usual but fear we would concede so much more.

I just dunno
 
P.S. for the folk having a go at the players. It's clear Lampard couldn't set up a team to save his life. Judge the players under an actual manager. Boys like Coady will keep Everton up if coached correctly.
 

I think out of the two, all considered - that being who gives us the best chance of staying up - Dyche is the right, pragmatic choice. If we go down, he'll probably be lashed but if not, he's had 2 goes at promotion before and twice been promoted.

Bielsa, my immediate instinct was 'with this team?!' and a big swerve.

I've slowly convinced myself he'd be alright, but nah.

Go an look at his club career.

Quit one game into the season at Marseille - "I have finished my work here, I want to go home". Left Lazio after 2 days. Lille he lasted a few months. Same with Espanyol - joined July, got off in September.

He's a maverick, an if he couldnt be arsed with Marseille, Lazio an Espanyol - at 67 I'm not sure he'll be arsed with our nonsense.

Also have to consider motivation for the job. Dyche would love the job. Bielsa, is giving me Koeman vibes. All the reports are us having to convince him.

Ask me later an I'll be saying swerve Dyche an go Bielsa.

The big issue is the club needed to make changes much sooner - whoever we bring in now is on a hiding to nothing.
 
At this point, i honestly don't care any more. Who ever we get, half the fans or more will say its the wrong choice and wont give them time anyway. Theybwill blame the board for making the wrong choice and it will just follow the same cycle.

I actually tbing as bad as weve been, we still have a good chance of getting out of it with some stability, butvwe will never have stability. Our fans arent patient or forward thinking enough to let it happen.

I actually thought Moshiris video the other day was decent, and people still had a go. We literally cant win. So why even try?

For that reason, they might as well appoint the cheapest option and go again in the summer, whichever division we end up in.
 

GrandOldTeam said:
I think out of the two, all considered - that being who gives us the best chance of staying up - Dyche is the right, pragmatic choice. If we go down, he'll probably be lashed but if not, he's had 2 goes at promotion before and twice been promoted.

Bielsa, my immediate instinct was 'with this team?!' and a big swerve.

I've slowly convinced myself he'd be alright, but nah.

Go an look at his club career.

Quit one game into the season at Marseille - "I have finished my work here, I want to go home". Left Lazio after 2 days. Lille he lasted a few months. Same with Espanyol - joined July, got off in September.

He's a maverick, an if he couldnt be arsed with Marseille, Lazio an Espanyol - at 67 I'm not sure he'll be arsed with our nonsense.

Also have to consider motivation for the job. Dyche would love the job. Bielsa, is giving me Koeman vibes. All the reports are us having to convince him.

Ask me later an I'll be saying swerve Dyche an go Bielsa.

The big issue is the club needed to make changes much sooner - whoever we bring in now is on a hiding to nothing.
Click to expand...
Absolutely, but Koeman is the wrong analogy. He couldn't be less like Koeman. Koeman was all about whether we could further his career to give him the best chance of ever becoming Barcelona manager (check out the registration plate on his car when he was here).

Bielsa has to be convinced that a club is the right fit for him in terms of structure, ability to implement his methods etc etc. It isn't born out of ambition like Koeman, it's because he's the ultimate purist and he will swerve anything which doesn't meet his standards. FWIW it amazes me if he thinks we are a good fit for him as we are a basket case of a club and he'll get off the moment he realises this, but of the two managers, objectively speaking, if you're asking me which of them gives us a better opportunity to not be dreadful anymore it's Bielsa by a million miles. We may go down initially with him, but I've no more confidence that we'd stay up with Dyche
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top